29 Jan 2019 11:44:26
Let me ask a question, I won't ask for a poll cause there's enough of them on here. Reading the comments I see there's a big claim for Arfield to be dropped for Davis. What's everyone's opinion on that? I think that there's no way Arfield should be dropped, he was immense against Celtic, played a hand in all 3 goals at Livingston and when he's not playing we do miss him. Yes, he had a bad game at Killie, which seemed to have started this nonsense talk but come on guys, it's got to be Arfield all day. Yes Davis is good, but Davis today is different from Davis 7yrs ago.


1.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 11:49:13
I would have thought davis would have to prove himself, but on the other hand katic got dropped for worrell.


2.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 11:53:05
Arfield over Davis for now for me, doesn’t hurt to have an extra body in as the likelihood of Jack McCrorie and Arfield all playing every game between now and the end of the season is non existent. Injuries or suspension will soon create an opportunity for Davis and he has the ability to become a mainstay.


3.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 12:08:03
Arfield didn't have a good game against Killie because SG changed the formation. He completely snuffed out Broonie in the Old Firm game and was involved in all 3 goals last Sunday. On form, he must stay in the team!


4.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 12:48:51
Arfield until davis proves he is the better option.

Mcgregor
Tav goldson katic halliday/ barasic
Mccrorie jack
Candieas arfield kent
Morelos

That for me is our strongest team, its up to others to prove they deserve to start. I'm actually leaning towards halliday over barasic. I have yet to see barasic perform the way halliday did against celtic. 👍.


5.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 13:54:51
For me Arfield is the better player rn, Davis from 7 years ago was unplayable. I think many fans still think of Davis as this player but sadly I think he has lost it a bit.


6.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 14:07:02
Horses for courses surely. There will be games where we need a more creative midfielder, then Davis will come in. We have more depth now that doesn’t mean trying to fit everyone in a best 11. Before January we were all agreed that we needed a creative player to break teams down. Now we have that you’re arguing why he shouldn’t be in the first 11. Why not trust Gerrard (who has made mistakes and will yet) to make these decisions based on who we are up against, and the condition of our players who he sees training everyday?


7.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 14:09:40
Watched Davis closely when he came on on Sunday.
He was at least a yard behind play and did not give the impression of a seasoned International. Will reserve judgement as I think he deserves benefit of the doubt, but to me he was looking for a second or 2 every time the ball came close, and he should know, you don't get that up here!


8.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 14:33:36
Davis not match fit and has yet to prove himself. Hopefully tomorrow he and Defoe will go some way to justifying SG’s commitment to them. For me the jury remains out on both of them.


9.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 14:43:48
Let's just be happy guys that we've got both Davis and Arfield in our squad.


10.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 14:51:34
In my opinion Arfield is better at the moment, he is box to box all game.
Him and jack play well together when McRorie is sitting and breaking up play.
Davis needs to get some games in his legs as I totally agree with bar72 he looked at least a yard of the pace when he came on on Sunday.


11.) 29 Jan 2019
29 Jan 2019 17:14:17
Davis may have been a bit off the ace and looked for that 2 seconds when he had the ball as he has been playing in a league where he can do that for the past 6/ 7 years, he's going to need time to readjust to our league again, he will come good again no doubt about that.