13 Mar 2019 14:39:09
Well after last nights performance I'd have Shinnie in the middle of that park any day of the week energy, snapping in and around the midfielder battle and leadership qualities.


1.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 16:39:53
And to think there were people on here questioning if he was good enough 🤯 - sign him and McKenna.


2.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 18:22:46
Ross mcrorie is top drawer in middle of park.


3.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 18:26:03
Yes last night they fought for every ball and won but how many times per season are we in a battle like that. We currently have players that can compete in the middle of the park like jack McCrorie kamara Davis and rossiter. Don't try and tell me that shinnie is better than them.
Shinnie is not what we need, we need players that can take the ball in the middle and run at players and can score goals.

McKenna is out of our price range.


4.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 18:43:48
Great post Stewartyblue. I have no idea why we can't see this. It's crazy Windass 16 goals from midfield and although not a worldbeater ran full pace for 90. Jack and Kanara stroll about like pirlo etc when they cany beat Kilmarnock etc. We really are a shambles and a 51 percent win rate for Gerrard is not good.


5.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 18:56:02
Totally with you stewartyyblue.


6.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 19:14:49
Because shinnie constantly bullies everyone of our midfielders, has more heart and drive too👍.


7.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 19:29:55
Stewartyyblue am not trying to tell you anything am tell you he is better than those names you mentioned. Coop please don’t comment you’ll only ask for a poll👍🏻.


8.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 20:23:57
Gerrard has a 58 per cent win rate.


9.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 21:32:26
Tommyrangers/ supercooper - windass rose tinted Specs or what - he was single fish - thought he was a Player and turned up for 16 mins in each game . Never stopped running 🤯 - I will default to our managers position rather than listening to that rubbish. And to claim that shinnie isn’t better than what we have is naive. I have seen him twice in recent weeks be the best player in the midfield area again take off the specs. Bottom line is mcinnes knows how to play us and SG will have to work out how to change it.


10.) 13 Mar 2019
13 Mar 2019 21:43:42
It's all about opinions and in mine shinnie ain't any better than what we have. Yes he always seems to turn up against us but have you watched him in other games like against the unclean.
Jack, McCrorie, rossy and Kamara are all young players, who will grow and get better.
We don't need defensive midfielders we need attacking midfielders. We had 64% possession last night and failed to create no where near enough goal scoring chance. It was the same against them last week and against hibs.
If we don't have any young boys in the reserves that can play that position then SG need to either loan in or spend between 3.5 to 5 million getting that sort of player.


11.) 14 Mar 2019
14 Mar 2019 00:13:33
Gers 09 windass was that pish he got more last season than the rest of our midfield/ wingers combined. He'd have got a barrow load in this team.


12.) 14 Mar 2019
14 Mar 2019 00:33:34
Windass was the single softest player ever to wear the jersey. Absolutely zero heart and a total disgrace. Anyone who comes on here pining for him instantly loses any respect I might have had for their opinion.


13.) 14 Mar 2019
14 Mar 2019 06:03:57
Gers 09, simple question mate. In your opinion is graeme shinnie better than ryan jack? Both play in similar midfield positions and both hard tackling, defensive midfielders who allow the more forward thinking midfielders, to strut their stuff! We don't need a graeme shinnie type midfielder, imo we need a class killer ball, creative midfielder!
Shinnie is far too similar to what we've got at ibrox just now! He wouldn't get a start in our rangers midfield, as far as i'm concerned! You obviously differ, so who would you drop, in our current midfield, for graeme shinnie?


14.) 14 Mar 2019
14 Mar 2019 08:53:50
Windass scored away at hearts, hibs and Aberdeen last year, and at home against them! We got rid far too easily!


15.) 14 Mar 2019
14 Mar 2019 12:22:45
Carlos Pena had a good goals to games ratio, you gutted we got rid of him too?


16.) 16 Mar 2019
16 Mar 2019 14:06:13
Super
If the rumours are true, the manager will know what role shinnie will play - I personally feel it will be as left back, however will also give us midfield cover . I cannot take time hose on here seriously wanting windas back, he was an imposter and thought he was a player. No doubt he had talent but another who will never make the most of what he has . What’s the modern terminology- snowflake!