08 Oct 2019 11:04:22
Guys looking for your thoughts re some of our loan players, does anyone disagree and still think any of these players still have a chance. Imo I think that Middleton, Rossiter, Ruddens, will get no where near our first team in the future. I also think that Docherty and McCrorie are seriously going to struggle.

Imo I just think that we have moved on as a club and are looking for a better standard of player than any of the above.


1.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 11:17:07
middleton is still just a young lad. The rest? Who knows.


2.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 11:22:40
Rossiter himself seems to have written off his Rangers career Docherty and McCrorie I’m sure will have a future If they bide their time, Middleton not sure Rudden i'd agree with you Our one loan deal I can’t get head round is Andy King why did we bother?


3.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 11:32:48
I think McRorie, Middleton and Docherty should be given a chance.


4.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 12:53:16
I agree with Blue89, I feel the above 3 have something to offer, I'm actually disappointed that Docherty has not been given much game time since his return from Shrewsbury. I also want to see Defoe, and McGregor extending their contracts, and, young Robbie McCrorie becoming our back up keeper next season, I thinks Fod's is a good goalkeeper and has to move on for game time.


5.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 13:05:05
Rossiter very unlucky, I wish lad all the best for the future.


6.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 13:34:46
I tend to agree re rossiter not getting a renewed contract.
Also out of contract June 2020, firth, foderingham, Alnwick, Herrera and Holt, do not renew contracts. Good savings
Mcgregor, Davis, Defoe renew contracts
Halliday, probably move on
Flanagan, great cover both full back position, so I’d renew.
Thoughts guys.


7.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 14:03:30
Middleton, McCrorie and Docherty will be back. Whether they have a future beyond that is uncertain.


8.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 16:04:59
Middleton will be kept. as will McCrories (both) Alnwick and Fods both away. Firth may get another contract depending. Halliday will probably get another too.
Davo, shagger and Flan will hopefully get resigned.
doc, well as much as i'd like him to make it, alas he looks like he may not. Rossiter won't be kept. A number of the kids will fill in some gaps.
I'd expect a couple of new faces too at higher level.
Otherwise it will depend on sales as to what we do

All imo of course.


9.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 15:55:53
Who would any of them replace in the team? There are five in front of Docherty, Middleton can't get a start with Hivs, McCrorie is still a hopeful. Rossiter and Rudden are as good as away.


10.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 17:06:42
I would renew Fod's I still see him as having a future post Mcgregor and is a valuable number 2.
Halliday I think probably deserves a new deal assuming he knows he won't play much, he won't be on massive wages anyway and is a good figure in the squad.


11.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 17:39:09
middleton is 19, he's played in 5 games for hibs, starting 3, he's got 1 assist. We've got him signed up till 2023, so it looks very unlikely he's going to be leaving.


12.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 18:06:44
I was only referring to players whose contracts r up 2020.


13.) 08 Oct 2019
08 Oct 2019 21:06:01
McCrorie and Middleton should be given an opportunity to work their way back into the squad after loans. Also believe Docherty will get a run this season and equip himself well. If Halliday’s contract up in the summer think he will have opportunity to extend.


14.) 09 Oct 2019
09 Oct 2019 16:22:16
Not convinced about any of the others, but McRorie is top class. Some of the performances he has put in for his age have been great.