Rangers Rumours Member Posts


PapaBear's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
Correct Score Competition:

Not entered
Correct Score Competition
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing

No Profile Picture uploaded

Team: Rangers

Where from: Motherwell

Favourite player: Ally McCoist

Best team moment: Helicopter Sunday


Timezone: (GMT -2:00) Mid-Atlantic

PapaBear's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To PapaBear's Posts



To PapaBear's last 5 rumours posts


To PapaBear's last 5 banter posts


To PapaBear's last 5 rumour replies


To PapaBear's last 5 banter replies


PapaBear's rumours posts with other poster's replies to PapaBear's rumours posts


08 Jan 2017 00:27:08
Sunday papers reporting we're looking at Andrew considine of Aberdeen


1.) 08 Jan 2017 16:52:09
Now all Of the rumors this one will probably have the most truth to it a MW Type player (crap) going by his previous signings especially defenders at the onlt one mentioned who in reality wages we could afford, hope not but Probably true just remember a certain Forrester from the sheep a few seasons back!

2.) 08 Jan 2017 17:21:48
Don't remember a Forrester from the sheep.

3.) 08 Jan 2017 18:03:29
Who and when was Forrester from the sheeo mate?

4.) 08 Jan 2017 19:51:24
He means Ricky Foster. Jeez oh.

5.) 08 Jan 2017 20:25:11
Papabear, hearing that we will definitely sign jon toral (arsenal) and emerson hyndman (bournemouth), both 6 month loan deals and of course both are midfielders. Warbs is also hoping to tie up these 2 pre contract signings for next season, centre half andrew considine (aberdeen) and striker rushian hepburn-murphy (aston villa) . If we can agree a fee with both aberdeen and aston villa then warbs would like to sign both for rangers this month!



07 Jan 2017 12:01:57
Heard Ali crawford would jump at a chance to join us. This never happens but I actually do have a source as I know his girlfriend and a friend of mines is pally with Craig Watson at Hamilton who also said rangers is most likely for Crawford. Think it comes down to whether the interest from rangers is concrete as Crawford has spoke with members of Rangers recruitment team seemingly. If I hear anything else I'll pass it on.


1.) 07 Jan 2017 13:39:59
Of course he'd jump at the chance of joining us, it would like be winning the lottery for him. Sadly, he's nowhere near what we require.

2.) 07 Jan 2017 15:21:44
Agreed he is no were near good enuff!

3.) 07 Jan 2017 16:43:46
Is he really any worse than Holt and Halliday! At least he gets good write ups in the press. The last time Halliday had a game for us was against Celtic last season and he has been living on that since.

4.) 07 Jan 2017 18:45:31
Totally agree tomusa Halliday needs replaced and I would have Crawford over him any day of the week.

5.) 07 Jan 2017 21:21:08
No not at all if haliday played for Hamilton he would stand out like a sore thumb as a great player for them. its a totally different thing playing for rangers and Crawford is not good enuff at all.




PapaBear's banter posts with other poster's replies to PapaBear's banter posts


15 Mar 2017 16:22:09
It's no secret that we struggle with our CB's and this season Liam Lindsay has caught my eye. young, good centre back at 6ft 3. One to watch out for in the future imo and would like to see him join us. together with Bates I think that would be good options for us to have breaking through. Would keep Wilson as I think he is sold short and on his day can be really good. Hill I believe may retire and I would get rid of Kiernan as soon as possible. next season would like to see a good experience CB on Pedro's choice join us, Wilson, Bates, Lindsay and Senderos (only cause we won't be able to get rid of him and he has another year on his deal) .

Any CB's out there you guys would like to see us go for that's realistic?


1.) 15 Mar 2017 17:09:34
Does anyone else find it alarming how many times Wilson gets caught out by a bounce ball or misjudges the flight of the ball? My mate's a season ticket holder at Tynecastle and says it happened pretty regular with him at Hearts too.

2.) 15 Mar 2017 17:41:11
Kiernan is statistically our best defender wins more on the ground and in the air than any other CB. IF Pedro can coach the mistakes out him or change his style of play he's maybe worth another year.

3.) 15 Mar 2017 17:47:39
Lwdawson, totally agree with your comment. Wilson is shocking and gets nowhere near the abuse directed at Kiernan but makes far more mistakes and is also lazy at best. Dundee, Inverness, Parkhead to name but three places where he has single-handedly cocked up or misjudged the flight of a long ball.

4.) 15 Mar 2017 21:20:09
Kiernan is rank rotten and neither he or Wilson are the answer. Hopefully Warburton will take Kiernan to Forrest but that would seem to good to be true

5.) 16 Mar 2017 09:54:36
I'd like us to go for the young hamilton CB. I think he's there captain also?!
I reckon having him and bates ( both youngish ) with Wilson ( still reckon there is a player there if he has 2 FBs who defend ) and getting in another experienced CB would give us good options.
I'd chase Senderos and hopefully Warburton comes in for Kiernan.

6.) 16 Mar 2017 17:03:55
Papabear, like you, i really like the look of partick thistle centre half, liam lindsay, and have actually posted on here before, as to us going to try and sign him! The centre half i would like us to sign up for next season, is the current ipswich town centre half, christophe berra!

7.) 16 Mar 2017 17:40:19
Wilson is a liability like Kieran both should b sold at end of season get two decent central defenders and a new captain as Wallace is never a leader, get a solid defense first and someone to boss the midfield.

8.) 16 Mar 2017 18:09:03
Kiernan is actually a better defender than Wilson imo

9.) 16 Mar 2017 19:29:16
Kiernan maybe wins more on the ground or in the air but it's usually 25 yards out of position when he should be nowhere near it. Hill and Wilson have looked by far the most solid pairing this year even though they're both left sided.

10.) 16 Mar 2017 23:28:49
kyle bartley played with us knows what its about and has got better over time plus i'd love to see him go through brown again that was a brilliant challange lol

11.) 16 Mar 2017 23:33:02
Papa bear, I scouted younger players for many years and if I was scouting Lindsay I'd be at the point of getting a second opinion because there's a player there, but he might lack a bit of mobility and of course he's still raw. My verdict would be worth a punt, he's 21, give him a season or two and see what's there.



03 Mar 2017 14:08:40
Seemingly Caxinha's club have rubbished claims he's met with Rangers for the manager role. He was in Qatar yesterday to take charge of a game which in itself doesn't say much as he could have flown back to Qatar on Tuesday evening after being interviewed.

Also, media reporting Wilson has asked for more time to consider move to Rangers. If he's not jumping at the chance to come to us then I doubt his commitment if he does decide to come and would have him as a short term flight risk. From the beginning I preferred Mitchell of Tottenham as he was more responsible for Southampton's current setup than Wilson who is getting credit for someone else's work and imo has made poor signings for Southampton since joining them.


1.) 03 Mar 2017 15:07:56
Pedro was in London last week supposedly for talks with Rangers not a few days ago

2.) 03 Mar 2017 20:16:52
its beginning to look like our directors are backing the wrong horses here and are in danger making a huge mistake. Why can't they act like normal people for once and forget the DOF role for now and get big Eck in to steady the ship. and if he gets us 2nd or 3rd then give him the bloody job permanently!

3.) 03 Mar 2017 20:07:00
Wilson will be seeking assurances over what will be available to him. Not a lot I'd imagine.

4.) 04 Mar 2017 12:24:09
Poor signings? Like gabbiadini, van dijk, redmond, Romeu? Southampton r absolutely class!

5.) 04 Mar 2017 12:25:58
He was probably told a figure he could live with then thr next meeting that he was supposed to sign on the dotted line they let him know that's over the next few years and he has changed his mind.
Thats just my thinking



29 Jan 2017 10:58:49
My thoughts on yesterday's game:
1) Miller has earned a contract extension, no doubt
2) halliday continues to struggle DM role
3) kiernan remains a bomb scare and could very easily have been sent off
4) I fear we won't see MoH start a game again for us this season and will be sold in the summer
5) Hyndman is everything I hoped Holt would be. Boys a player and shows just how below standard Holt is for me
6) McGhee was livid, this pleases me


1.) 29 Jan 2017 16:44:42
Spot on mate but I wouldn't lose any sleep if ohalleran didn't play again



22 Jan 2017 01:53:56
After today's game, I reckon we don't have any one particular 1st choice set of players except for foddy, hill, mckay and Miller. Read a lot of comments in how waghorn should start, dodoo should get his chance, moh is due a run out etc. But looking at it closer and waghorn and dodoo were awful against teams the come out at us (Celtic, Aberdeen, hearts etc. ) And yet excel against Hamilton, Partick thistle and then Motherwell today when waghorn came on. Imo we have 2 sets of players where games against teams that park behind the ball needs the waghorns and dodoos but against the teams that don't camp behind the ball, players like garner are our best option. Issue is, I don't think Warburton realises this. Lastly, kiernan is truly awful. Can't wait to get rid of the guy as its horror show after horror show with him.


1.) 22 Jan 2017 09:38:09
Good post PapaBear. We have a nucleus of players, if utilised correctly, that could give us the basis to move forward.

2.) 22 Jan 2017 12:15:06
We do have a nucleus of players but we are way short in the striking department. I am still not convinced MW knows his best eleven. For eighty three minutes it was what we are all used to by now but the last seven minutes we definitely got out of jail. Once more we lost a goal to a bread and butter cross into the box. We need players in the opponents box, too many times yesterday we had nobody posing a threat and the attack petered out. We need an out and out striker for sure.

3.) 22 Jan 2017 15:36:31
Yesterday summed keirnan up I thought he was having good game but you're always waiting on that mistake and along it came when he lost mount at goal.



30 Aug 2016 16:15:47
Just been thinking and wondering why our attack had been so flat in recent months. Long gone are the incisive one touch penetrating moves and now we have back and forth slow passing. Then it dawned on me when Warburton said (paraphrasing) "that's not us, we don't play like that on the training ground. Need to transfer what we do there to the matches". No wonder our attack is ineffective in spl just now, they train against the same defense that suffered against Kris Boyd's electrifying pace!


1.) 30 Aug 2016 17:07:20
When Holt is out the team it lacks that pace and directness that he produces on a regular basis.

MW team selection has been surprising to say the least using three holding midfielders in games and leaving it late to bring on a decisive playmaker.

Windass and Holt are of that type and will make a significant difference.

2.) 30 Aug 2016 17:34:11
We are missing waghorn up there.

3.) 30 Aug 2016 17:54:18
Give niko a run! The guy has class and vision to make chances, isn't going to get match sharp with ten minute cameos.

4.) 30 Aug 2016 18:34:25
Niko is as sharp as he is going to get.
He is a luxury and an impact sub at best.




PapaBear's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

19 Sep 2016 10:36:34
I may be wide of the mark here as I'm no employment law expert but I thought given the nature of footballers contracts that it doesn't fall under the standard rules of employment law? Put it this way, you cannot under any circumstance "trade" a standard employee with transfer fees, however you can in football as they are essentially treated as assets on their balance sheets as available for sale assets. The contracts that govern footballers are unique to that industry and unless you know employment law specific to sports players, I'm not convinced they fall under the standard rules. It may very well be easier to punt barton that some believe and I recall Fran Sandaza's case of dismissal which didn't last very long.




Click To View This Thread

27 Aug 2016 11:48:31
I'm not a fan of kiernan as I think his positioning, aerial ability and tackling are all really poor. However the goal last night was not kiernans fault for once. He correctly faced the oncoming attacker as being the nearest defender. Hill should in that scenario track the runner. To be out sprinted by Boyd, sickening stuff!





PapaBear's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

22 Mar 2017 11:22:20
I work with John's sister and got her to ask him if he would come to Rangers. He said not a chance. I do like him as a player and think he can have a bright future in the Scotland squad but he needs to move away from Hibs imo and his attitude towards that question will hold him back in his career and shows a lack of ambition. Can't see celtic going for him so if he wanted to move up a level rangers would be his best option and yet he has no interest. Off down south to be lost in the wilderness of mediocrity of the English football it is then!




Click To View This Thread

01 Mar 2017 10:00:48
Ironically we could really do with a manager with Lennon's traits. Could you imagine he was appointed and the meltdown that would occur from the celtic lot? We've had players cross the divide before but never a manager.




Click To View This Thread

28 Feb 2017 11:43:58
Your expectations are pretty high BarcaBear. While those qualities would be ideal, I can't think of anyone that fits your criteria. Would be better if you rank your criteria from most important to least important to give a better sense of what you deem an acceptable manager for us.




Click To View This Thread

20 Feb 2017 16:43:27
This is an incredibly valid point and one I made privately to my friends at the beginning of the season. Simply put, the expectation level placed on players who are frankly from mediocre backgrounds is completely misplaced. The players were signed by Warburton and while they were good enough for the Scottish championship, how could we realistically expect a bunch of English league 1 level players who couldn't even get a game for their clubs at the time to compete with Celtic in the league. I saw this coming although I had hoped that there was some hidden talent with them all that Warburton saw that we as fans couldn't. Even Windass who seems to be quite popular amongst our support is pretty poor and while he has the odd moment of setting up a chance, his overall contribution like the rest in the squad is pretty dire. I'm currently feeling very despondent at the situation we find ourselves in and it speaks volumes against those players we signed when Barrie McKay, a product of a shoddy youth system and ignored to the point that he was almost released until Warburton happened to give him a shot, is better than the lot of them. When we played Hearts, I remember looking through their squad and picking out all the players I would take from them in a heartbeat to replace the mediocrity we currently have. Would take Paterson instead of Tavernier, Souttar instead of Kiernan (heck I'd take a traffic cone instead of Kiernan), Kitchen as our DM, Cowie in place of Halliday, Walker instead of waghorn, Johnson instead of Garner, even Hamilton instead of foddy. Even Nicholson when he came on looked impressive and all that is just from ONE team. Warburton has went to England and cherry picked mediocre players from a terrible league (I will never buy that league one is a better standard than SPL as I believe Celtic, Aberdeen and hearts would beat those teams with most of their players being English championship level imo) . The lack of passion in our team is down to these guys. They are league 1 level for a reason, they never strived to be the best, to be winners, to be Rangers quality.




Click To View This Thread

29 Jan 2017 19:24:51
Dth100, I get what u are saying and understand your frustration. The reason why I think it's a fluke season is this is Celtic's best ever start since Lisbon lions (their best ever team) . Compare to Celtic of last season and it's a huge difference for them. They've made 3 notable changes, a new manager, Sinclair and dembele. Remember that player they signed for £3m odd, bangura was it? Didn't work out. It just so happened this season it did work out. I don't think Celtic have fluked any games as they've been the better team for most of them, but their season as a whole is a fluke, a one off. I doubt it'll be repeated again next season and I doubt they'll make any further signings that'll have the same impact on them as Sinclair has had.