Rangers Banter Archive November 11 2012

 

Use our rumours form to send us rangers transfer rumours.


11 Nov 2012 23:41:04
Smith being back is the start of the end for McCoist, if he hadnt been humiliated in 2 cups and struggling to win a game every second week he wouldn't be there.

Believable13 Unbelievable12

The decision was taken over a week ago and McCoist was allowed to call for Walter over several days to make it look better for Ally.
It's actually a slap in the face and confirmation of failure. His failure on the field bankrupted the oldco and he was doing the same to fragile newco.

Agree12 Disagree13

So when John Greig joined the bored s a non executive director it was a slap in the face of Dick Advocate or Big Eck (can't remember who was manager at the time) because he once managed Rangers. Walter Smith is a director now nothing else

Agree8 Disagree7

@1, I think you saying ally bankrupted the oldco is a lot of b****cks, it was murray and whyte who done this so please don't blame ally for that, yes the results are poor but having to build a team from scratch almost and having no pre season does not help, however if at the end of the season and we have not won the league then yeah maybe his time will have come to be removed, lets all get behind the team and support them to the hilt, with Walter being back at the club this may make things better and get the fans to fully back greens plans, we were always going to be dubious no matter who took over, back the club and we will be back a stronger club in the spl in a few years, andygers74 watp

Agree8 Disagree9

This is a PR coup, legend back as director.

Like Grieg as director, which did not stop admin/liquidation..... ?

Does Smith have experience as director or non-exec, as its a tough job to hild back directors from screwing the business?

So +press for few days, stops any investigation into green and hearts debts.... but sticking plaster solution ? or real fix ?

Agree6 Disagree5

What a load of crap gets posted on here i for one welcome walter home now we have a man the supporter know at the top table

Agree11 Disagree5

Op @1 you two are embarrassing smith is there to help run the football side of the bussiness and will sit in the directors box. So this leaves a big problem with your diagnosis that ally is finished. Green is trying to build trust with the fans and bringing watty in helps this I don't think watty would have came back if he hadn't been shown evidence that rangers were being run right and there was no shady bussiness going on. Ally will continue to be manager for some time. So this leads me to the conclusion that you two are on the wined up or you have been using illegal substances and are on one crazy trip

Agree10 Disagree6

Can anyone tell me how smith 'helping to run the footballing side of the business...' Isn't going to involve getting involved with McCoist? One visit therefore by Smith to Murray Park will shatter those illusions. A non exec director not involved in day to day football or team selection shouldn't be anywhere near MP. Will the smuggle him in and out?

Agree4 Disagree6

@7. It doesn't matter where Watty goes either around Ibrox or MP or even just talking to Ally.......someone will always accuse him of interfering in the footballing side of things. He's damned either way, as there will always be those wanting to create something from nothing. bigbaz

Agree3 Disagree1

11 Nov 2012 23:23:31
Ok will ask again why has green asked Alloa to wait six weeks before they get paid their gate money...What is the problem

Believable19 Unbelievable10

Why don't you ask Charles Green himself, don't think you'll find him here.....try Ibrox.

Agree13 Disagree9

The season ticket money isn't in the bank untouched.
The £500k offer to Hearts was a bluff knowing mad vlad wouldn't take it. Because Green doesn't have it. The rapid Vienna £800k is disastrous.
Alloa's money isn't a small issue it's very worrying.

Agree19 Disagree12

The season ticket probably is in bank and untouched (metro bank, 3 months notice before a withdrawal, account max £2million ??) ..... ?

But need clarity on all this little issues....

prospectus keeps going back a week, dual-contract review gets delayed, a perfect strom brewing....

Agree8 Disagree3

Where is the story? Just googled it and nothing. Until I see a report which states Alloa are owed and weve missed the payment date Im not worried. If it exists then please give a link. Maybe Rangers accountants treat it as an invoice so have x ammount of days to pay? Tescos pay 90 days after invoice for example. CheltBlue

Agree5 Disagree7

#OP - Where are you getting this rumour about Alloa? I appreciate this is a rumour site but i wish people would cut out posting random crap to stir s*** up!!

Agree7 Disagree9

Where's this story about that rangers have asked for six weeks to pay Alloa I can't find it and I would think that if there was one it would be a big story as surely the sum involved wont be huge if true this would indicate newco in dire financial difficulty and I'm sure the media would have field day. As for saying the offer to hearts was a bluff how can you say that green could never know what Romanov would say and imagine Romanov accepted and if green never had the money now that would have been a disaster. So therefore I must conclude that the ops post is total tripe and nothing but scaremongering

Agree6 Disagree4

@4 standard payment terms as per SFA for gate money between clubs is 30 days.

Agree5 Disagree0

This is not a rumour ..Phone Alloa all true

Agree9 Disagree6

Same link about mortgaging the season tickets was asked for last year - wasn't believed till in your face. Wake up and ask the question rather than hiding/hoping it isn't true.

Agree6 Disagree4

Ha ha. Phone alloa. Like they'll tell little ole me the ins and outs of their finances. please inform us where the story is not saying its bull. Just would prefer to hear from official source. Ps is it on rangers tax case yet? {The Ed039's Note - There is no story here)

Agree1 Disagree2

@7 At least thats sorted out then. 30 days less watever has passed, then its a story worth mentioning. CheltBlue

Agree0 Disagree0

@10 no denial from the Green PR brigade so far. They are usually quick off the mark when they can deny.

Agree2 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 21:10:07
Sir WS joins board with Ian Harte? Welcome back Wattie

Believable18 Unbelievable12

Ed I'm under the impression those involved in the management of a liquidated club cannot hold association club management positions for 5 years. Is this correct? I know oldco isn't liquidated yet but when liquidated will smith and hart have to stand down? {The Ed039's Note - I dont think they had posts that would influence such a rule, especially Smith, he was never on the board. Hart was part of the Blue Knights I think, but it would have depended on his position on the old board)

Agree4 Disagree2

11 Nov 2012 22:28:52
Is he back to pay his EBT? {The Ed039's Note - Seriously, where do you guys get this pi$h from?)

Agree7 Disagree9

It's a desperate attempt to save the club. Div3 income with Spl level outgoings is killing this club. Few quite rightly interested in buying shares. Smith persuaded its desperate and against his better judgement lending his name to this venture and also, contrary to statements, quite obviously there to improve footballing performance.
(The truth is always contrary to statements at Ibrox).

Agree6 Disagree16

At@2 you are all aware that mr smith knew about the EBTs so what's new ....b

Agree1 Disagree2

The club has gone from the spl to sfl3 overnight, Regardless of how you feel about Ally, a lot of managers and clubs would struggle with that. I don't believe Walter smith coming in should be seen as a bad thing! He knows the heartbeat of the club, and will help to steer the club in a whole new direction. I would like to see him oversee the whole coaching system, not just a board member.

Agree4 Disagree3

Re 3] against his better judgement, why would he, behave. There are some people where regardless of what Green does it will never be right.

Agree6 Disagree2

@2/3 I take it you are not rangers fans and how do you know what rangers finances are just because you wish this to be the case doesn't mean it is. Now lets try and look at this sensibly rangers income is predicted to be 30% less than if in SPL due to cut in season ticket price and tv and league money. But rangers have cut 70% of the wage bill from 26mil last year to 7mil this year so on that alone they are 40% better of plus more people paying at gate still costs about 15/20 quid a pop thus bringing in more money than if 48 thousand season tickets had been bought plus an increase in hospitality and bovril and pie sales plus more merchandise being bought will probably mean rangers will be better of in the third than in the SPL the 30% we are losing by not being in the SPL is wiped out twice over in the saving of wages. Plus we ain't paying 5/6 mil a year on paying debt. I think rangers should generate about 25/30mil income this season at a modest estimate outgoings 7mil in wages and a generous 7mil for bills comes to 14mil that leaves around 11/16mil profit. Now if the share issue goes through there's another 20 mil which would mean between 31/36 mil in bank. Now I know our Celtic friends will hate the idea that this could be true and us as rangers fans need to be careful with our expectations of green. But if he is genuine in his promises then sorry I can't see how rangers shouldn't be in a healthy financial situation

Agree4 Disagree3

@6, aye and they all wear green tinted specs.

Agree0 Disagree0

Ed039.. please point us to the statement from walter that he was not one of the 88 who had EBTS....?

as cant find it in google, sure its there.. ? {The Ed039's Note - Can you please point me in the direction of a shred of evidence that says Walter Smith was paid by an EBT, if you can find it and BBC cant then you are doing well)

Agree1 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 20:54:49
ed am watching the real maddrid game and the rain is bad a no if the game ends it will be replayed but see if a player has been booked will the carry on to the next game ex ronaldo get a yellow card then in the replay he gets booked would he be sent off


SM {The Ed039's Note - If it is postponed the game will continue from where it left off, if all the same players are available they will play and all stats, ie bookings, sending offs and goals etc will count. If they start from the start again then they wont count)

Believable1 Unbelievable3

ED can you tell me of any game that was postponed because of weather has been started where they left off ?.I have never heard oif that before
Tam {Ed001's Note - I am sure I have seen some where the rain has been so heavy they had to bring the players in. All the ones I have seen were restarted from the beginning though and the game was abandoned. So cards etc didn't count, as the match was wiped from the records.}

Agree1 Disagree2

@1 Cheers for that ed
Tam

Agree0 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 20:45:59
Walter Returns To Rangers


The Rangers Football Club today announced the appointment of two non-executive directors to the Club's board of directors.


Former Manager Walter Smith and Ian Hart take their place on the board of directors with immediate effect.

Carling1873

Believable10 Unbelievable9

Non execs are basically advisors bringing knowledge from outside the organisation.

Agree5 Disagree2

11 Nov 2012 20:39:03
Walter Smith back at Rangers SPN

Believable10 Unbelievable9

11 Nov 2012 20:38:53
sir walters back!

Believable12 Unbelievable13

Why is there 6 people disagreeing.... what do u disagree with?

BigBear

Agree3 Disagree3

Wasting your time big bear, low mentality!!1

Agree5 Disagree7

@1: maybe they disagree with him being back at the club? It's not that difficult to work out.

Agree4 Disagree1

11 Nov 2012 20:38:45
Welcome back Walter smith , we've been expecting you......

Believable13 Unbelievable14

11 Nov 2012 20:38:33
a web site latest.....

walter smith is back at ibrox on the board as a non executive director,
your thoughts??

Believable10 Unbelievable12

11 Nov 2012 20:34:50
Ed just been told Walter Smith has decided to join up at Rangers you heard anything? {The Ed039's Note - Yes, returned as non executive director)

Believable8 Unbelievable9

11 Nov 2012 20:33:03
Walter Smith is back at Rangers as a non executive director, he is appointed along with retired businessman Ian Hart who was originally part of the Blue Knights consortium.

Believable8 Unbelievable7

11 Nov 2012 17:57:48
Just like to say congrats to St Johnstone on becoming the joint best team in the world
GCUK

Believable42 Unbelievable7

Nice one OP ... short,funny and witty. Geo the Ger

Agree15 Disagree6

By that gauge what did losing to Scotland's worst team make Rangers?

Agree16 Disagree10

Hear hear, garlar07

Agree6 Disagree4

Think Killie's recent 2-0 win at Parkhead makes them best club team in world. Saints will just have to settle for joint second.

Agree11 Disagree2

Every knows that barca have been on the slide for the last 18 months they didnt even reach the final last year

Agree12 Disagree10

Touche!

Miko x

Agree1 Disagree5

Since you all agree st Johnston is the best now that your myths about the spl being crap is all wrong right? And that it is something aswome that came away from the cheating, it has to since all of you were watching the game, obsess who?

Agree6 Disagree6

@5: on the slide? Have you checked the league table? And the CL group table?

Agree6 Disagree1

OP Methinks it will be a very long time before you meet a big team like ST.Johnstone in a league game.

Agree7 Disagree1

Someone get the net ready I think I've got a few nibbles lol. At least Miko took it as it was meant lol.
GCUK

Agree0 Disagree0

I would like to congratulate all the spl teams for making it a fun and exciting league for a change just shows what you can do when you remove the corruption ...

Agree10 Disagree9

It's a one off - the players were tired after 20% possession on Wednesday.
JMG

Agree4 Disagree0

Such a 'fun and exciting' league - HA! -, the attendances overall are down this season, where are all these fans who told their Chairmen 'Yes we will come and fill the grounds if you vote No? Are they disguised as seats, further evidence from SKY/ESPN states the average viewing figures for the SPL are much lower than watching a team in the SLF3. Wonder who that could be? Remove the corruption, who are you kidding, it runs our game here - only it's hides itself in the mantra of Sporting Intergrity.

Agree11 Disagree4

@7: can u repeat that in english?

BigBear

Agree3 Disagree0

Nice one13 @5 the game wasn't on the telly so how could we be watching but if we were we would have been watching st Johnstone not Celtic remember as rangers fans we support 2 teams rangers and anyone playing Celtic. By the way just to clear this obsession thing up you lot say we are a new team who have only existed for 4 months have no history have never played the mighty Celtic who are by far the best team in the world except from Kilmarnock Dundee united and st Johnstone have never won anything but you lot cannot stop going on about us wishing us more harm and pain and spending several hours a day on this site telling us all that we will be back in admin by Xmas now that is what you call commitment and oh yeah that word you all hate a unhealthy obsession with all things rangers/sevco which ever one you prefer lol

Agree4 Disagree3

@11. You must be one of the few Celtic fans who think it is fun and exciting in the SPL. Some of your supporters are far from happy with the amount of fans at the game yesterday especially after selling out the game midweek. It can't be that exciting for them. bigbaz

Agree2 Disagree1

11 Nov 2012 17:38:30
Well there we go what a funny old game, Celtic played Barcelona at home and won and Barcelona are, as we've been told, the bestest team in the big wide world and it's being written into the tims history book or comic books as we speak.
Soooooo St Johnstone drew with the team that beat the bestest team in the big wide world sooo that must mean they could beat Barcelona too.
In fact St Johnstone are probably better than Barcelona and Celtic combined 'cos they got a point from Porkheid and Celtic even had an extra day to prepare for it.
The tims are now second in the SPL, is that not embarrassing for a club that size? The EPL? no chance.

Believable15 Unbelievable10

@OP: not really embarrassing and they have a game in hand which, going by many Rangers fans' logic last year, is an automatic three points lol

Agree8 Disagree3

Is being top of the 3rd not a embarresment for a club the the size of la rangers, the spl? no chance, see i can be a **** as well,garlar07

Agree9 Disagree2

Lennon is a lucky manager-last season got away with it cos of gers troubles - and this season without gers proves he's jist rubbish.

Agree8 Disagree13

Very embarrassing. But they are not stuggling to beat village teams!

Agree10 Disagree3

@3: did Rangers' troubles help Lennon's team on Wednesday night too?

Agree7 Disagree0

I guess you alright rigt about st jhonston beating us and they are the best now, so I guess that means the spl is doing GREAT without rangers and more myths from you and the end of spl ppl eh?

Agree8 Disagree2

Is'nt it nice to see gers fans having a chuckle again.Did some misfortune happen to someone/somebody.

Agree7 Disagree1

Garla07, a club Rangers size, thought they were a newco with no history so how are they a big club, oh you fell into a trap their didn't you.

Agree4 Disagree3

Lennon is the luckiest manager septic has had but hel be found out shortly

Agree8 Disagree7

No i did,nt fall into a trap,my missus is a ger,i would not risk her wrath,she vets everything i write here,and besides ger,s are gonna be on top 2nite and i don,t have a game in hand garlar07

Agree0 Disagree1

PMSL, Garlar07. As I was in need of a laugh I hope you have a satisfactorily exciting score draw that makes it all the way to penalties! Better have your shooting boots on though, nothing worse than missing the target when you are expecting to score, lol!

Brian

Agree0 Disagree2

@Brian hard fought match went into extra time,end result 2 all draw,ger took an early lead,but i clawed it back,look forward to replay next year lol,garlaid07

Agree0 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 17:33:05
Hearts are looking for £2million from fans to keep them going until summer. What happens in the summer to make this situation go away?

Blueice

Believable6 Unbelievable1

Hearts wont survive anybody that buys shares are a fool

Agree8 Disagree3

11 Nov 2012 17:28:47
Isn't the world of sphell football fickle after the world beaters given a doze of reality today with saint J drawing with them does this make saint J also beter than the mighty Barca lol this is a tongue in cheek post

Believable5 Unbelievable7

Then again st johnstone have a better chance of playing barca than rangers do who know,s maybe they could beat them, garlar07

Agree7 Disagree2

It makes st jonhston miles better than your 3rd division club

Agree8 Disagree1

We might be 3rd division but at least our fans are faithful unlike the supposed best supporters in the world.

BigBear

Agree0 Disagree3

@4 Dont see how Celtic fans are unfaithful, not one fan calling for Lennys head, already read a few The Rangers fans saying they wont be back cause the standard is dire and calling for Super Ally to go on numerous occasions, especially after Stirling Albion.

G93

Agree2 Disagree0

@G93 - Some of your fans were calling for NL's head after the Kilmarnock game. Both sets of fans are fickle,neither is better than the others in that sense. When Ally or Neil win, then they're the greatest - lose and it's get them out time. Celtic fans (and some Rangers fans) have rightly been lauding Celtic/NL after Wednesdays great result at Parkhead, but that will soon be forgotten if they have a bad run of results in the SPL, if it wasn't for the European results to soothe the fans ire, then Mr Lennon would be treading on thin ice with some of his teams support. bigbaz {The Ed039's Note - Its a good post Baz with some good points, but the Champions League is the be all and end all for most folk. And I dont think over the course of the SPL season that other teams will be able to go the distance with Celtic in the SPL or Rangers in Div 3 for that matter)

Agree0 Disagree1

@ bigbaz some fair points, but I'm sure you will agree that with the league relatively guaranteed for Celtic, making an impact in Europe was Celtics priority this season. I'm disappointed with the results after European games, they aren't good enough but I don't think too many Celtic fans are panicking. Like I said on other posts, there is a 2 and a half month gap between the Spartak game and the knockout rounds of CL/Europa League (should we qualify), if the results don't improve during this period and Celtic don't create a decent lead at the top then serious questions will begin to be asked. If Celtic win the league with 80 points and get to the last 16 then that will be a successful season, same as The Rangers getting out of SFL3,and I don't think there is any doubt both Celtic and The Rangers will win the league by 15 points minimum.

G93

Agree1 Disagree0

@ 3 your fans will be judged next season when their asked to pay full spl prices for 2nd division that green has already stated will happen

Agree3 Disagree0

Agree Ed, even though Celtic seem to be mis-firing in the SPL at the mo I fully expect them to win the league at a canter even if they lose 7 or 8 games. Exactly the same for Rangers, both teams are still to dominant for their respective leagues no matter the slip-ups. bigbaz

Agree0 Disagree0

@6. G93- as you say maybe Celtic have taken their eye off of domestic footie with the European games at the mo, i still fully expect them win the SPL comfortably, just as i fully expect the gers to win SFL3 easily. Neil Lennon will no doubt make sure his players 're-assert' their mindset back to the SPL during the euro break, of this I am certain. bigbaz

Agree0 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 17:14:01
Answering Bobby Lennox ... Bobby! Bobby! Bobby! How can you say Celtic are the best club in the world, when they're not even the best in Glasgow?! Languishing in SFL3 is the most successful club in world football. They have amassed a WR 115 domestic trophies, which includes a WR of 54 titles. They have also set numerous World, European and British attendance records over their 140 year history. Their traveling support is second to none, especially when an estimated 200,000 were in Manchester, 2008. They also appeared in 4 European Finals, winning one, in 1972. The mind boggles what could happen if a club, like that, did win the coveted Champions League, or even appeared in a final. There's more to add about this great club, but I believe you now know the true answer ... RANGERS! Geo the Ger

Believable21 Unbelievable16

Yep and i am sure Manchester police would love to see them back again.....

Agree9 Disagree2

Or the club in D3 has won nothing - depends on your point of view. And only Rangers fans are claiming Celtic were the best team in the world lol

Agree8 Disagree3

Killie st johnstone ross county septic best in the world what a laugh

Agree4 Disagree3

Surely the best in Glasgow will be the one from Glasgow highest up the league?

Agree5 Disagree3

@3 Stirling Annan Peterhead Berwick Queen of the South

Barcelona Spartak Benfica

G93

Agree8 Disagree2

11 Nov 2012 16:24:05
Regarding the haerts debate, from another point of view, say hearts are prospectively going bust.liquidation, logically Charlie G could look at that likelyhood and expect we do not end up paying hearts a penny, to offer now is from that point of view generous as they will in all event probably be liquidated the amount of times they are late paying players and the amount of debt they have... not saying it is right but it is to some degree generous... george {The Ed039's Note - Even if Hearts are liquidated then Charles Green will still need to pay for Lee Wallace, any future monies owed goes towards the creditors pot, should it come to that)

Believable4 Unbelievable7

This guy's a crank Charles Green is generous!

Agree1 Disagree3

Showing signs of oldco already, not wanting to pay debts how low can you lot get? Let us pay up and start the way we intend to go to get us back to the top. Can't believe some poeple, no wonder the World never mind Rangers is in the state it is. UNBELEIVABLE
Bobby

Agree2 Disagree1

Cheers ed I wondered about that... george

Agree0 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 12:31:00
Still the moans persist about a lack of Government help regards what happened to Rangers. Think about what criteria the Government usually require to get involved in that. First off it is generally a bigger company than Rangers where thousands of jobs are affected, not hundreds. Secondly the bulk of Rangers expenditure was coming from some very highly paid individuals, most better paid than any cabinet member. Would there be a desire to help that when the club themselves showed no real inclination towards reducing that level of pay? I doubt it.

On what grounds does the Goverment usually get involved? None of them affected Rangers hugely. Was a change in currency value to blame? No. Were competitors, domestic and foreign under-pricing the club? No. Did a vital resource to the product soar in price? (Oil, coal, whatever.) No.

Pure and simply, Rangers overspent. I have never wanted that type of politics involved in sport. Manchester City being bequeathed a stadium after the Commonwealth Games while Arsenal go trophyless for how long after financing their own new ground. Spurs and West Ham fighting over the Olympic Stadium, pleading poverty to revamp their own grounds or move while paying players £100,000's of pounds a week. It doesn't wash with me at all.

I cant think of one appropriate football team collapse where standard Governmental intervention would be appropriate. Gretna - any club financed by an individual and not ran within its generated income budget is but a heart attack away from potential disaster. The same would apply to Chelsea and Manchester City.

Portsmouth - Mad over-spending, even an FA Cup and Europe the next season never helped them. What did that club have to win to break even? I shudder at the thought.

Leeds and Rangers are the most guilty of all. "We chased the dream" said Peter Ridsdale. Personally I wouldn't leave that guy in charge of an ice cream van.

Sure Rangers debt was down to £18m when Whyte took over but there was still the big tax case to be sorted and by the time he left it had rocketed to £56m again. Remember a bunch of the already well paid Ibrox stars got bumper pay rises when he started, a great policy if selling them on is still to be considered but it didn't quite work out that way did it? All it did was burden the club with a higher expenditure till administration and given that Whyte was sure the CVA would fail, he must also have been aware of TUPE. (Say what you will about him but he has forgot more about ailing companies than most of us will ever know.)

So basically I don't know on what grounds Rangers fans are up in arms about a lack of FA or Government assistance. This wasn't a company faced with an unexpected economic event that caught them cold. The words "you're spending too much, you're spending too much, you're spending too much." Were there for all to see. And as a general rule that doesn't get much sympathy or financial support.

Gaz

Believable18 Unbelievable7

Sdm was warned for decades. The relationship between him and the boss at bank of Scotland needs investigating. Why did BoS give him ridiculous sums of money with no hope of being repaid?

Agree12 Disagree5

FFS @1, did you not notice 4 or 5 years ago banks going under, would think that mr Murray is a very small fish in massive pond. Or was it all rangers fault for the world wide economy collapse?

Agree1 Disagree3

This is a very fair point. Can't argue with it. Probably one of the best and well worded posts on here.

Agree6 Disagree1

Cheers 3) dictionary was working overtime :)

Gaz

Agree1 Disagree2

11 Nov 2012 11:15:14
with all murray parks coaches, professional full time staff, lush top of the range pitches, and facilities in fitness management nutricion etc. why are we still producing no talent coming through. lets face it the current crop of young players in the first team are useless and would never have been near any first team under any other circumstances. any other era and they would be off to partick, dunbarton, alloa etc

Believable13 Unbelievable12

Now they will get a chance to prove if they are up to it. They will also, if successful, be able to silence people like you who are far too negative.

Agree10 Disagree10

Sorry to admit, you're right. Compare Germans and Dutch if u like but they're basic young lads are naturally gifted talents to start with. Athletic and fit. We don't have the initial level of gifted talent.

Agree6 Disagree1

Facilities pointless if the young lads play fifa12 more than real fitba in the streets...

Agree8 Disagree0

Not negative at all but it annoys me that the best rangers can do is play kids who would never be anywhere near the first team any other way than no choice. we had far better reserve players in the past who never got a game. these kids are 1st division class at best if that.

Agree7 Disagree0

@4

Thats all we need at the moment. If they are 1st div standard, we should have more than enough to get back to back promotions. Lets face it, that is all that matters, flashy football or not.

Agree1 Disagree3

What more can Rangers do? There's only so much training you can provide a lad, it's down to their natural talent and the lad's themselves progress. State of the art training facilities isn't goin to make a player better. What WILL make these young lads better is plenty of game time in the first team, it's a different ball game, pardon the pun, on the pitch than it is at training!

TTG

Agree0 Disagree3

Think ur being a bit harsh on some of the players I have thought that McKay and Aird have looked quite good and I am confident both will improve. Not so sure about MacLeod as his passing isn't the best however all 3 are very young and should only be judged after a season or 2 {The Ed039's Note - I am more optimistic about MacLeod's future than the other 2 TBH)

Agree0 Disagree1

11 Nov 2012 10:12:05
Just having a moan here Ed and clearly I'm bias in my views but here goes. I'm sick to death of all the paranoia surrounding Celtic and their 2-1 win last week over Barcelona. Sure a very good result but the hysteria in the media is way over the top. Celtic only won the league last season as Rangers began their descent into liquidation, there is no doubt about that, and that is the only trophy they won. They are a mediocre team at best. They are sitting level on points at the top of the SPL with some pretty ordinary results and performances. They beat Barcelona - a good result and may well qualify for the last 16 of the CL. So what? They haven't won anything yet this season and certainly won't progress beyond the last 16 of the CL. We've seen this hysteria before yet all Rangers get in terms of coverage is negativity, no matter how good a team we've got. We won three SPL titles in a row before last season but got little credit. I for one am sick to death of the overhype coverage of Lennon and Celtic. Achieve what Walter Smith did and maybe you can start to crow. Footnote - Gers' youngsters are looking better every week, so I think we are on the way back, though it will take three or four years. WATP.

Believable15 Unbelievable18

Celtics journey into the champions league has earned them £22m to date, as well as £100K for every SPL club.
Forgive them if the league hasn't taken top priority so far.
As for last, Celtic clawed back a 15 point deficit to win the league by 20 points, a 35 point swing. A marvellous achievement in anybody's language.

Agree12 Disagree6

What has celtic got to do with rangers coming back in 3/4 years?what a pointless rant.

Agree14 Disagree2

What did walter achieve. 9 league titles, countles exits at group stage of champions league and a run to europa league final.

all of this was achieved at a cost of liqudation and the death of rangers, now theres a tribute act performing in division 3.

the celtic board no better than to overspend and financial dope there way to the top of the scottish game.

and with regard to the press the rangers currently get, maybe if they were actually storming the league with the youth players then maybe theyd get more coverage.

without mcculloch this season rangers would be midtable at best (in additon mcculloch can no longer cut it week in week out at the highest level (SPL).

Agree8 Disagree4

@1, a little picky with your facts for that one. Surely 10 point deduction should have been mentioned!!!!

Agree3 Disagree1

@3,

You say that, but you don t know for certain what is going on at celtic behind doors.

Agree1 Disagree2

Walter won 9 league titles ?? did he buy out the rights to the ones souness won as part of the asset sale ??

Agree5 Disagree2

@6 If you want to include titles when he was assistant to Souness Walters record would be 12.

Agree1 Disagree0

#1 - 22m to date ? I doubt you got this figure from Celtic - I look forward to seeing it in the accounts - 22m to date ? Your biggest crowd to date was 55000 and the 3 match package was the cheapest you've ever charged, ITV won't show your games and your put on a website 4 to allow other bigger games on the other channels- think of a number, double it and add on a couple of mil ....... Granted you have done brilliantly but why do you have to waste it with this nonsense ?

Agree5 Disagree1

@ 7 i dont i want you to stick to the facts in that walter as manager didnt win 9 in a row and neither combined won 12 in a row either

Agree0 Disagree0

@8: you do realise that 55,000 is the capacity on CL nights?

Agree0 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 01:09:22
Doesn't say much about our 2 first choice CBS, both out injuried and we keep a clean sheet.

Believable2 Unbelievable2

It's against the sixth bottom team in British football lol

Agree5 Disagree2

11 Nov 2012 00:24:45
Yet another good day at ibrox....team looked strong (opposition granted) still dont like two sitting midfielders....need a spark or a danger man to create in the centre....just thinking its a position we are needing someone.... both midfielders kept dropping in next to the cb and looking for the ball in that area..push up and go create....both cb can pass the ball.

Believable2 Unbelievable17

11 Nov 2012 10:11:42
After all the ex bears comments on here about Celtic's "negative" tactics against Barcelona ( read that again BARCELONA) yet your esteemed manager still plays 2 sitting midfielders in the 3rd Division (read that again THIRD DIVISION) and at home.
All season your team has been negative in away matches in 3rd division. I take it you are all happy with these tactics against mighty part time/amateur teams in 3rd Division?
One final point after the awe inspiring mural by the Green Brigade on Wednesday I see some of your fans attempted a poor imitation yesterday, why not ask GB for some help? lol Timalloy

Agree11 Disagree11

Not worth dissecting mate. Peterhead are fifth bottom in the bottom tier of British fitbaw.

Agree6 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 23:38:30
@1...

Totally missed the point...as a rangers fan i want to see us go and attack teams and as a direct result we need something creative in the cm position...we are not trying to compare rangers to celtic....its a pointless effort....we are playing negative tactics as are celtic...even my wife asked why celtic had that many players on the park (she is not a football fan) neither is anyone who thinks your tactics were great on wed....the result was great....but the performance was rotten....if you went toe to tie with them and got that result i would be signing your praises...unfortunately you sat behind the ball and tried to stop them shooting!! I hope you qualify for the next round just to see how much a mockery you make of the spl by catching up hibs after xmas while playing in euope but to be fair... a monkey could manage a team with celtic resources and win the most uncompetative league in history....in fact one is and is struggling to win it...check the reresults yea

Agree0 Disagree1

@3 Is that last comment an admittance that SFL3 is too challenging for The Rangers? When we lost, it didnt matter how long we held out for, we still lost, then we win, we had no possession and it was too defensive? And I think Aberdeen Hibs Dundee United are able to provide more competition to Celtic that Annan Stirling Peterhead can to The Rangers, just look at the results yea

G93

Agree1 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 00:17:34
Think Green has made a big error in trying to offer Hearts £500k now instead of the £800k when due. It is no doubt good business sense but he has misread this situation. This will be seen as trying to take advantage of Hearts problems.

Whilst I could not care less about Hearts it would have been far better PR to offer to pay them £400k now as a gesture.

However I remember Vlads rantings when voting on our SPL entrance so why should we help them. They gave us no help in fact anything but, but this offer should not have been made. If they wanted a deal I am sure they would have asked. Big mistake Green

Believable20 Unbelievable12

Hearts gave you no help, neither did any other team.
What makes you think that the rules should've been bent and bypassed to allow a new club direct entry into the SPL?

Would you as a The rangers supporter have voted a new club straight into the SPL?
Didn't think so, rules are there for a reason.

Agree6 Disagree2

Screw pr. football is a business pure and simple

Agree5 Disagree1

Y should we make any gesturre at all? What have hearts fans/owners done for us? I agree it was a brass neck asking to settle it at 500k however if it gotthem out of a hole then it might have been their best option. Romanov is "loaning" them the money so its pushing them further in debt. I want them to go into admin etc... Let's see if they receive the same venomous attitude?

Agree2 Disagree4

ED,if we do not offer cash now and Hearts go route similar to our own what is situation with the 800k. If there is any chance that it means it does not need paid in full then is it not a generous offer from Green. {Ed001's Note - no, any money owed will still need to be collected to pay the creditors.}

Agree2 Disagree3

Jim duffy was on radio clyde during the week and he said when teams are owed money from clubs and find themself in trouble money wise then clubs do make a deal on what is owed to them ie 800,000 then 500,000 is the kind of deal that could be struck between clubs ,so charles green is only doing what other clubs do so hes no the villian hes made out to be . hearts are not in a position to scoff at any offer.

Agree6 Disagree3

Remember hearts may be skint but big vlad is defo not he will get all his money from you lot

Agree4 Disagree1

I might be wrong with this but did Vlad not offer the same deal about 7 months ago when we were in administration but we could not afford it then.

Agree1 Disagree1

I hear Green now has cheek to ask Alloa for 6 weeks grace to pay them their share of last week's gate money, is money that tight we are back to late payment to balance the books.

Agree8 Disagree3

This kind of deal does happen. Southampton accepted reduced deal on both Walcott and bale while they were struggling few years back. No big thing. We offered they said no. So what. Just means theyare confident of survival. Good luck to em. {The Ed039's Note - Or Mad Vlad just doesnt want to play)

Agree0 Disagree0

11 Nov 2012 00:11:30
Talking about the youngsters being the way forward for Scottish football, by all parties in Scottish set up including the Goverment yet they abolished the second team setup 2 years ago. Why? I can only think that ITFC Ross County, Aberdeen and Celtic were the only teams who seemed to want to keep this going when it happened so all the bigger clubs including ourselves need to take a look at themselves. We do a lot of talking when it come to encouraging youngsters on but that all it is talk. If we had done this earlier the Scottish game would be in a better state now, even using young foreign players to play alongside our boys can only bring a better class of football
Because they started there coaching earlier and at clubs with better coaching systems.
Our football is crying out for change that must start at the bottom. The buck stops at the top. We are in a good position where we are let's do it.
Bobby

Believable7 Unbelievable0

Are you talking about the reserve league? Most teams didnt have enough players to make up their first team nevermind their second team. Aswell as the financial cost it simply was no longer viable

Agree0 Disagree0

One of my biggest grouses this year is the fact that Rangers didn't bother putting up a team for the new Scottish Under 20s League.

I can only imagine this was a cost cutting exercise but surely it's an utterly false economy.

BARNEY BEAR

Agree2 Disagree0

For the most part youth coaching in Scotland isn't good, that includes Rangers. If your son is a talented youth and an EPL side want him, he'll learn more down there and get better coached than up here. We need international youth training staff not former SPL players passing on how they got trained 25 years ago.

Agree0 Disagree0

Is there still a rangers ladies team?

Agree1 Disagree0

 
Change Consent