Rangers Banter Archive September 23 2015

 

Use our rumours form to send us rangers transfer rumours.


23 Sep 2015 22:21:05
Tonight's games show how little there is between SPL and leading championship teams.



24 Sep 2015 06:41:06
Ha ha Doiger the phrase "grasping at straws" comes to mind
I wish I was your bookie, how are your 10-0 bets coming on bye the way lol



24 Sep 2015 07:07:42
Pity the nite before didn't show that eh!! Lol



24 Sep 2015 10:19:45
If yous lot showed the same enthusiasm for your own mob as you obsess over ours, you could probably swell your gate to over the 14000 mark for a game not being televised live, had to check to make sure you actually were at home.



24 Sep 2015 10:54:19
Yeah, 2-0 hammering of mighty Raith rovers.



24 Sep 2015 11:43:17
sotonbear
Well said mate, somebody will get sacked for giving out the real crowd instead of Mr Liewell's made up numbers



24 Sep 2015 14:58:24
Figures & TRIFC just don't go! When's the Audited figures being released?



24 Sep 2015 17:41:14
Steffantos
What happened to the CELTIC FOOTBALL & ATHLETIC CLUB, we would all like to know



24 Sep 2015 18:27:54
I heard a strong rumour that Liewell had ordered a couple of light aircraft to do a kind of Febreze fly past last night just before the game. I guess that would explain the poor attendance.



24 Sep 2015 18:48:41
Only 14000 at the game last nite because the smell is getting unbearable Celtic and soap don't go its magic u no



25 Sep 2015 12:56:45
Steffantos
Still waiting for your answer?



23 Sep 2015 21:48:44
Well that's the" reality check" theorists had their argument blown out the water with lowly championship hibs putting Scotland's form team to the sword tonight .



24 Sep 2015 09:37:42
What!!!! That has nufin to do with reality check bud the reality check was done on u lot not aberdeen hahahaha



24 Sep 2015 10:25:34
So how was there not a reality check for Aberdeen? they got done by a very average Championship side, we got done by a fairly average premier league side? it would have been a completely different scoreline if our defence did make those 3 mistakes.



24 Sep 2015 10:44:42
Getting beat off a team the league above u is seen as a horror yet a certain team(Celtic) get beat by a team with 10 men (Aberdeen) after there assistant had already claimed that the other teams in the spl were not good enough to even bother Celtic(lol!!!!) Hmm more than one team have had a reality check this season.



24 Sep 2015 14:51:33
Onlyshowaround the reality check is and only for you lot as I said before your lot where giving it large about running over the top of st johnstone a team in a higher league stating u could finish easy top 4 so its a reality check for you lot as u where dreaming that u could compete with the big boys as for the sheep well the got done by let's say a lesser team so its a shock to there fans they got beat BUT AS IV STATED YOU LOT GOT BEAT OF BIGGER TEAM AND IT WAS A SHOCKER HAHAHA that's your REALITY CHECK THERE hail hail



24 Sep 2015 15:40:43
shadyboy
Humped out of champions league QUALIFIER by the mighty Malmo (big improvement from last year) humped by 10 men, just you stay in your wee bubble son



24 Sep 2015 16:55:32
Shandybhoy: I think come next season we will be able to compete with the so called big boys.



24 Sep 2015 18:14:34
AUTHENTIC Professional Clubs ( EA Sports ) playing week in week out V TRIFC will be well up for it after being overlooked & under rated by the so called Challenger's for The SPL!



24 Sep 2015 18:55:17
Keep playing with your games console steff practice makes perfect maybe your team could beat Malmö on that



24 Sep 2015 18:30:06
Shandybhoy, I really think you should try and calm down before you post - and for god's sake take off the boxing gloves



23 Sep 2015 19:32:39
Think we played well in parts last night but I always thought against better opposition a proper Defensive Midfielder would be needed to tighten things up. Halliday is a good player and can easily handle it at championship level but we need someone like Eustace in there for the harder games to cover for the full backs when they go forward and push Halliday forward in place of Holt/Zalalem.
From last nights performance it showed we need a CDM, a striker and quite possibly a CB, although a would like to see the two we've got with a Eustace type player in front of them first.
I'm quite willing to wait till after Xmas at least before saying any of this team are not good enough for SPFL though, could simply have been a case of bad day at the office, we all have them.



24 Sep 2015 10:02:37
"...we need someone like Eustace in there..."

How do you know? Has anyone ever seen him play? There have been posts on here almost asking if he even exists.



24 Sep 2015 18:32:51
In the old words of Corporal Jones - 'dont panic!' Let's go with the flow. One bad game doesn't mean we're a bad side. I keep saying this but look at Hibs last night. And remember St Johnstone beat them at home last season. Was there a great hullaballoo about that?



23 Sep 2015 18:49:37
at the game last night and made a point of watching danny wilson closely as he has never convinced me his movement and positional sense leaves a lot to be desired he has no pace and was found wanting on more than 1 occasion last night against a beter standatd of player than he has been use to over the last ccouple a years for me personaly he is not the answer just hope he can prove me wrong.



23 Sep 2015 17:02:45
I believe that if Waghorn scores as he should have Or oduwhas shot that hit the bar goes in then we would have won.

Certainly no gulf in class, yes they pressed harder and faster but we played the better football throughout and I thought St Johnstone players were knackered towards the end of the game.

If we draw them in the scottish cup in 6 months I would expect a completely different result and would be confident we would beat them comfortably.

Still going in the right direction!



23 Sep 2015 19:57:31
i would expect a different result if playing them on saturday its not often i agree with g spiers of the herald this time i do



24 Sep 2015 17:04:58
If buts and maybe lol stef. Funny how u didn't mention Macleans miss of the season.Oh and just for clarification that u expect to beat them in 6 months. U expected that 6 months ago and 6 months before that and so on. But it ain't happened. Did u expect to beat Motherwell in the play off, or did u expect to beat hearts to the title. Some have even mentioned how Hearts are rotten and their bubble has burst . Do you even realise what your saying? This is a team that beat you by 24 points last season lol.



24 Sep 2015 17:10:45
Stef: I agree, it was the same against Motherwell at Ibrox, they pressed and hit us with quick attacks, we have the football but we need to play in a quick direct way on the break against SPL teams.



24 Sep 2015 18:02:37
rayman
Did you expect to beat a team ranked 134TH in europe



24 Sep 2015 18:35:01
Rayman
Wat are you taking about? 6 months and 6 months and 6 months! What a load of pish you are talking!



23 Sep 2015 10:46:58
Is it just me or does anyone else think that the lad oduwa needs to start releasing the ball earlier watched the game last night and he is definitely a player with a lot of potential but at times can be a bit greedy in possession fancy flicks and tricks are good to watch and see but at times just find a team mate rather than try showboating a few times he went past a player then went back to beat him again when we are losing 3-1



23 Sep 2015 15:43:51
Oduwa just faced a slightly harder and better quality of defender and marking he is at Rangers for exactly that reason to toughen him up as the defenders in the EPL are lightyears ahead of SPFL and he needs to be far sharper/tougher before Spurs will want to risk him in EPL.

One bonus is the Atletico Madrid attention might well fade a bit now lolol

KT



23 Sep 2015 18:11:38
He is on loan to learn,,,,, that's why we got him and that's why we have the other loaness.
The point being once they do start learning and will be off.......with us making nothing other than their games played.
This will unfortunately be the norm for a number of years as we can't afford to buy in the transfer markets like we use too.
There is also the worry that maybe this is exactly why he is out on loan.... simple facts may be that he is just not good enough to play in a higher league now or ever.



23 Sep 2015 17:05:58
IF 2015: Agree, he is some player but he does overdo it and I noticed last night he took one more flick or move when he could have gone past his guy, he has done that often, if only he would be more direct and get the ball in quicker.



25 Sep 2015 08:56:01
Yeah i think the lad will have a bright future he just needs to learn that he needs to walk before he can run so to speak once you have gone past your man get that pass away or cross delivered when we are winning 3-1 by all means show us a bit of trickery but when we are behind just knuckle down and do what is needed and that's not showboating



23 Sep 2015 10:36:23
I think the result has to be taken in context, in the Championship the players get that extra bit of time to make a pass etc. the difference is last night St Johnstone closed play down much faster and pressed more.

as you would expect from a team from a higher league. I am sure Mr Warburton will address this in training. Overall this was an excellent learning opportunity and showed we can compete..the stats prove it, I certainly didn't take as a "Doing" just a mixture of slackness and probably naivety. We are on the right track and will only get better.



23 Sep 2015 16:39:06
And don't forget - St Johnstone beat Celtic at Parkhead last season. Let's put it into context. We are not that bad. We don't need massive investment to compete against the teams in the top flight, including Celtic



23 Sep 2015 16:58:43
My god, it's not even 24hrs and seeker you've convinced yourself that rangers will win premier league next year, everything is Rosie again, no problem



23 Sep 2015 17:09:08
Geddes: I agree, it wasn't a doing, we were just up against a more clinical team who were more streetwise than teams we have played this season, but we put up a good show in the second half and it's just about being clinical again.



23 Sep 2015 21:47:04
Memaself
Look at the results tonight. Do you think Hibs are better than Rangers? No? Well they just beat a full strength sheep side 2-0. And everybody is saying we should be terrified of them and Septic. celtic just struggled to beat Raith who we crushed 5-0. It's a one off game in the cups. Anything can happen



24 Sep 2015 08:41:31
Seeker, the system rangers play is wide open for counter attack, yes good going forward but up against a decent defence and quick forwards you'll lose goals



23 Sep 2015 06:22:16
Have to put my hand up and say called that one so wrong a mile out that's why bookies are rich and I am not a good gambler

I thought we were closer to top of SPFL than we are King is correct 5 top quality needed for next year but let's focus on the positives we are better than the rest in Championship so we need to come out fighting and show that in the next 3 games

Think it is far better this happened now than had we played Celtic as then it could have been worse plus embarrassing. At least we can get Eustace in looks like we need him and the defence sorted out (Ball in for Kiernan it seems now) before we possibly face an SPFL in Scottish Cup later in season.

KT



23 Sep 2015 13:57:11
Am i the only person who thought St Johnstones second goal should have been given offside going by the new rules? Their number 9 was clearly interfering with play with being practically in front of the goalie when the ball was struck? I'm not taking anything away from the goal, it was a peach but rules are there for a reason. I would also mention i thought the referee was poor and made some strange decisions such as booking Tav for the slightest of pulls yet letting Davidson away with a rugby tackle 2 minutes later. Anyway, now that we've been brought back to reality, do you all think we are going with the right tactics? I personlly think we should either find some sort of DM to sit in front of the back 2 or go 3-5-1-1 and play 3 at the back with Tav and Wallace playing as wingbacks. I'd put Oduwa just behind Waghorn with Halliday, Holt and Mackay as the other 3 in Midfield and drop Miller and Zelalem to the bench. What's your thoughts?



{Ed039's Note - Cant be chopping goals off for that, could have had 2 keepers and still wouldnt have saved that shot)

23 Sep 2015 13:53:36
My Post Mortem:

Firstly this is not the end of the world. It does show us we have a way to go and lessons need to be learned. However being out one cup is not going to affect our season greatly.

The team and tactics:
The mantra all season is we will play our game and let others worry. This works when the other teams have little to offer however the opposition in this case had studied us and altered their game in order to undo us. We need to know our opposition better.

Players who didn't suck entirely: Foderingham (had little to chance), Tavernier (tried relentlessly), Kiernan was niave but battled all the way. Holt was our best midfielder. Waggy - well at least he tried.

Disappointments: Wilson looked lost. Communication between centre backs was abyssmal. Wallace was invisible for most parts and as our captain did not step up! Halliday - bad day at the office. Zelalem too lightweight and seemed to struggle with less time on ball. Oduwa needs to drive at defenders more consistently. He had the beating of them when he tried but opted out too often. Miller - another senior who shrunk when he should have stood up.

We looked frightened to drive at them. For the majority of the game I found myself going nuts because no-one wanted to drive into the box with the ball.



23 Sep 2015 10:52:19
Y r people being so negative we r in the re building process give it a chance and johnnyg we've played in lower leagues with full houses so that's why we r the best fans fed up with all the moaning remember warburton is learning up here aswel so let's just keep getting behind the club let's not act like the other side of glasgow and calling for heads and slagging players off



23 Sep 2015 11:31:10
It amazes me all the people trying to blame wilson and kiernan, at times they were the only 2 defending against 3-4 players lol.. it's the way we play now we will concede goals.. you can't say the game was boring. St Johnstone deserve some amount of credit.



23 Sep 2015 11:40:00
Scotty bang on the money mate, it is a learning curve for all, if we were offered our current position in July I think most of us would have snapped the hand off, the team will almost certainly improve, and in MW and DW I think we have potentially the best management team in Scotland, and in them we must trust they WILL get us there.



23 Sep 2015 12:34:49
The best management team in Scotland. Here we go. The arrogance is back already. You are a good championship team.



23 Sep 2015 13:01:26
Martybhoy3? Arrogance? It wasn't our coach that said the league was too easy! It was john heed the baw Collins! Just u worry about the smelly mob m8



23 Sep 2015 13:53:35
Mary where was the arrogance in my post, it was purely my observation and opinion of where our management team are and their potential in the future, didn't notice you put delilah and Collins up as a valid argument, thankfully yous don't have the money to get shot of them, and as long as that's the case the arrogant wee song u sing about 10 in a row is nothing more than a laughable ditty.



23 Sep 2015 13:43:17
Martyboy- Yesterday you said we were an average team if that, now today it's a good championship team, not bad average to good in 24 hours wonder what it will be in 6 months



23 Sep 2015 16:19:24
Sotonbear I think 10 in a row is more realistic than ever after that performance last nite!! Let's not forget St Johnstone had played 4 away games before last nite and won none of them!! So the only thing that's laughable is your statement about your management team! And am I wrong in saying Ronnie has won titles in 2 countries! Many has your new saviour won?? Will I tell u??? Lol and as for we don't have the money if we decided to get rid of him and JC! Another load of garbage!!! Let's not bring up teams not having money pal! Pot kettle and black springs to mind! Lol



23 Sep 2015 12:14:03
in the cold light of day we were not so good in the previous 2 games and basically you can't win every game. what warburton said was correct, saints were not miles in front us, we had chances that in other games were goals but we lost bad goals last night, or if you like punished for mistakes. we will lose goals but should score more than we lose.

andy halliday had his worst game in a rangers jersey, oduwa was largely innefective due to saints marking as was the lad from arsenal. but there is no point in going off at a tangent saying we need 6 players or whatever. one defeat in twelve if there had been a poll at the start of the season asking if we would settled for 1 defeat in 12 we would have thought we were in 7th heaven.

we must say that's the game over now we must now concentrate on the next league game against morton which our bread and butter depends on so let's give warburton and co the same level of support and let them get on with the job in hand



23 Sep 2015 17:16:03
BiGWULL : Big game on Sunday and of course a tough one, look at Morton's win last night and always a tricky match at Cappielow.



23 Sep 2015 19:30:50
Dh88, what yardstick did you measure your team by when they got horsed by Morton in the League Cup or Inverness in the Scottish Cup?



23 Sep 2015 21:07:00
Horsed by Morton and iness! I don't remember us getting horsed pal!! Aye we got beat but at no stage were getting pumped 3 nil!!! Now that's a horsing!!! Horsed!!! Hahaha aye nae bother! And what yardstick do u judge your mob when Morton could beat us yet u couldn't even manage a shot on goal against us !!! Now that was a 2 nil horsing if I ever seen one!!! Lol



23 Sep 2015 10:17:26
As much as I love watching us play good attacking football, I hate watchin us defend.
Sorry but I posted here (twice) that we would be exploited at the back by spl teams - even Hibs were unlucky not to score 4 against us.
I totally appreciate what W&W are doing but am concerned with their lack of tactical flexibility. Every team knows how to play against us now - park the bus an hit us on the counter with their fastest strikers.
If we play like Barcelona we need players like Barcelona. OK, the point being, we either become a bit more tactically flexible or carry on 4-3-3 hoping that we improve greatly (which we should ). Either way we need to invest in better quality which has been promised by DK. Defence is an embarrassment, considering we have DW as coach. Keirnan and Wilson were exposed yet again. If we r going full out attack we need a solid reliable defence simple as.
Also, I see Tavernier (our best player) as an attacking right midfielder. The guy gives 100% but is knackered running up and down all night. He"ll go for £8m in the summer anyway?



23 Sep 2015 16:15:22
£8 million....get real you could buy the whole team for half that amount...I would have thought last nights result would have put the brakes on such idiotic statements...he is a player playing in the second tier of Scottish football let's see him in the premiership or even Europe before laying £8 million price tags on someone from the English lower leagues playing well in a semi part time league in Scotland



23 Sep 2015 20:01:04
JohnnyG
The "evaluation" (which was a question and not a statement as u incorrectly stated ) was based on the £11.5m 'tic sold Van Dijk for. I rate Tavernier higher than Van Dijk, but that's my personal opinion. Based on your calculation you seem to rate Van Dijk as almost 3 times more valuable than the entire Rangers team!
Which is more idiotic - my question or your statement ?



{Ed039's Note - One is as bad as the other it would seem)

23 Sep 2015 08:50:46
Disappointing result last night but maybe everyone should calm down and look at it for a minute.

We were caught out at the back plain and simple. We have enough in defence for the championship but Wilson is being caught out pace wise quite often now. The defence coming up to support the midfield is leaving too much distance for them to cover on the counter attack. A tactic that all teams we play now will now adopt. They have to sit deeper or drop Wilson for Ball.

Anyway, maybe last night had to happen. We were all getting a little carried away with how good we have been. The team has hit a lull over the last few games scoring less and now defeated. These players hadn't tasted defeat until now and possibly its a good thing that they have. They seem like a tight knit group and play for the full 90 mins. Look at the pressure applied in the last half hour last night. let's give them the benefit of the doubt and look at the positives rather than negatives. We are on the way back and better this happened in League Cup rather than Scottish Cup. In Warburton we trust.



23 Sep 2015 10:30:18
I agree airus blue. As I've said before and others too, there was no way we were going to go throughout the entire season without losing or drawing games. Even in our nine-in-a-row years we lost games! Not getting the chance to see many games as I live on the south coast of England, I had avidly read all the reports in newspapers and comments on here and was looking forward to the game. I was disappointed. St. Johnstone were nothing special though they did win the Scottish Cup last season. The third goal killed any chance of coming back. Had we scored that goal early in the second half then it would have been a different story. I thought that when we went forward we did so quickly and with pace. Outstanding player for me was Waghorn. Defence looks shaky in the middle and don't fancy the goalkeeper. I like Tavernier and Wallace. I'd have played Barrie Mackay from the start and maybe now it is time to give Shiels, Ball, Hardie and Aird a run. No need to panic though - I'd rather be out of the cups and win the league at a canter. Hearts' bubble has burst in the SPL with three straight defeats so they are beginning to find it hard to adjust to the higher level.



23 Sep 2015 11:15:42
U can't just ignore the negatives of which there were plenty. How many great saves did their keeper make? Face it we were comfortably beaten by an average team. That performance is where we are at the moment and there is still a big gap between us and average premiership sides let alone the Celtics and Aberdeens



23 Sep 2015 13:12:18
Who said there wasn't negatives...what I am saying is were in a process of becoming the better team that we want to be. It can't happen over night and has only been three months since this team was assembled. We are ahead of plan but have a ways to go yet to be able to compete.



23 Sep 2015 17:05:54
Alrus, it sounds to me your towing the warburton party line, the way the team is set up is the problem, and I think he didn't show st Johnstone the respect they were due. A well drilled team, and let's face it, are not known for scoring lots of goals.



23 Sep 2015 08:28:16
Pride comes before a fall.

We do not have a direct approach when going into the box, or for that matter not going into the box, as was the case. Time and time again we passed the ball around the outside of the box instead of driving through. IMO this was due to the naivety of the players.

I have been saying for a few weeks that we need a striker, and as it would appear a strong holding midfielder.

I would not be too disheartened with the score and the disappointment as we have been told by MW that this team is a work in progress, and IMO I totally agree with him.

MW and DW will analyse and dissect this performance and determine were we need to strengthen for the premiership - remember our main aim is to be ready for next seasons premiership where every team will be trying to teach us a lesson and be totally psyched up for each and every one of our games - this is our main aim, anything else is a bonus.

We all knew that we were going to suffer a defeat at some time, so it should not have came as a surprise that we would fall to a premiership side - it is how we react to that defeat and move on - hopefully our next opponents will be put to the sword.

As MW has already told us he has already made plans to identify players in the January window it would be interesting to know if those plans have been changed or sped up.

The BlueBells are Blue.



23 Sep 2015 13:47:36
"...interesting to know if those plans have been .... sped up."

It's called the January window for a reason. You can't make January come any sooner.



23 Sep 2015 16:07:07
You can if they are loan players or free agents, and by cancelling contracts you can free up monies thereby bringing in those players.

Also, maybes, perhaps and could be's discussed with directors can be positively firmed up and confirmed as will be's.

Understand?



23 Sep 2015 15:20:16
It will be more loan players (soft loans will be needed to get to Xmas & then again to get thru the season)



23 Sep 2015 17:11:23
Aye ready, do you just keep saying things until you believe them as gospel, you can't buy or get a loan player before January, you can sign an out of contract player yes. As for financing this, are you suggesting you can cancel a players contract



{Ed039's Note - You can cancel a players contract but they will look for a pay off as they then wont be able to sign for a club until the transfer windows open again)

23 Sep 2015 07:56:43
cant believe the negative attitude on here. so we got beat. if the team were all duds as suggested then why are we clear at top of championship. every team raises there game against rangers and celtic. the team is young and only been together a few month. we didn't play well and the players probably believed there own hype. our objective is to get out the league.



23 Sep 2015 11:17:00
We are playing against a lot of part time teams in the division and have a huge budget compared to them. That's why we are top



22 Sep 2015 23:30:39
Disappointing result but no team goes through a season unbeaten in all league and cup games. Reality check time!

fodderingham. Makes me nervous
Tavernier. Great going forward
Wilson. Uninspiring
Kiernan Slow, poor
Holt. Jury's out
Wallace. Good
Mackay. Great - why didn't he start?
Halliday. Poor
Oduwa. Flattered to deceive
Zelalem. Good in flashes
Miller. Time to go
Waghorn Great player
Shield. OK
Law. Poor



23 Sep 2015 10:13:44
A fair but pretty harsh assessment. I'm seeing Fodderingham as a quality goalkeeper. It's probably too young a team and we got a total reality check last night and we're missing a player who can actually put the ball in the back of the net with his head. Crossing into the box is proving pointless.

I didn't see Sheils or Law adding anything when they came on and I battle to share some posts on here enthusing about the Northern Irishman. I wonder if he would have been shown the door with the other 12 at the end of last season if his contract had been up.



23 Sep 2015 11:18:24
Not sure I agree with Waghorn and McKay being great but your observations were pretty much spot on



23 Sep 2015 08:35:39
Foderingham made one great and one good save early on. Defence left him at the goals.
Cant agree about Waghorn and disagree about Wallace last night



23 Sep 2015 09:24:51
I think you are right Doiger. It's a reality check. I think everybody, including myself to a certain extent, was getting swept away in the euphoria. Yes I expected more from the game, but I can put it down to St Johnstone upping their game while we have been dipping a little over the past 2 or 3 games.

Do you know the game actually reminded me a lot of some of our past matches under Walter against Celtic. That time it was roles reversed as they huffed and puffed with Hughes and Valgaaren and threw everything at us while we picked them off with speedy players like Lovenkrands, McCann and Caniggia.

If you analyse the match, yes, they deserved to win but we had enough play and chances to warrant maybe a 2-3 reverse. And if Waggy's effort had gone in at 1-3, I think it might have been a different result.

For Dave Mackay to say they should have scored 5 or 6 goals with 30% of the play and 6 attempts at goal was crass and stupid to say the least. Maybe he is still a little raw after his many pumpings from Rangers during his career. Fair enough. Holt and Halliday were ineffectual, yes, but that doesn't make them bad players all of a sudden. I think we should all calm down.

We are still a young side and still developing. The manager has said his main intention was to get out of this division. We are playing in the championship but we are not a championship side. We are streets ahead of the other sides in the division. People have to remember this.

We have come a long way since the end of last season. I thought MW spoke well at the end. He mentioned sloppiness at a couple of the goals but didn't dwell on this. He said he had stressed to the players that they had only got together since the end of June. And he gave credit to St Johnstone. The man is a class act.



25 Sep 2015 22:44:44
Doiger: Peesonally I like Holt. I wouldn't say the jury was out on him.



 
Change Consent