Rangers Banter Archive July 03 2012

 

Use our rumours form to send us rangers transfer rumours.


03 Jul 2012 21:24:00
just like to say, i'm hoping we get into spl unlikley i know but you never know.... wonder what all they rangers fans ie mcgregor davis lafferty etc would do then? good luck tommorow rangers 1972 or whatever they will be called.. football always has a surprise and an away game at kilmarnock in 3-4 wks time could well happen.

Believable1 Unbelievable9

There's more chance of Susan Boyle getting on Mastermind

Agree10 Disagree1

Specialist subject - hairy eyebrows of the ages

Agree1 Disagree2

03 Jul 2012 21:18:36
Wouldn't surprise me at all if clubs change their vote at the 11th hour n vote in favour of a newco rangers in the spl. I think both the SFA n SPL clubs were banking on a slot in div1 for us but to be fair to SFL clubs they are right to.oppose as it seems they have been burdened with this issue as the SFA look to divert the attention away from any decision that will have a negative effect on scottish football. i have great sympothy for these sfl clubs n the position our FA have put them in.
Simple decision, sfa n spl clubs vote against a newco rangers then it has to be div3, no exceptions. A place in div1 is a cop out imo.
J1985

Believable6 Unbelievable5

03 Jul 2012 20:53:36
Time for us to set the agenda. 3rd Div boycott those who have kicked us while we are down. Weed out Scottish football to a smaller sustainable format.
Fed up with the no marks throwing their "weight" about

Believable2 Unbelievable13

Rangers support have voted 75% to go to div3.There is your answer Mr Green now get on with it or step aside.

Agree2 Disagree0

Yet you want us all to bow down to rangers. Have you not learned any humility from the fact almost every Scottish team wants you to start at the bottom even in the face of financial uncertainty. Your attitude makes no sense if Scottish clubs die then what's the point of rangers rebuilding, England will never be an option btw

Agree5 Disagree1

Like you have been throwing your weight around with your clubs will die nonsense?....green jhedi

Agree4 Disagree2

Again ....bully the rest....Rangers are currently the no mark with no power, has the reality not set in ....no one cares about a cheating club ...EBTS yes are legal ....dual contracts in SPL are not

Agree6 Disagree0

Our chairman has just apologised on behalf of the club, the fans are not to blame let's not blame others for the mess our club has caused Scottish football, and hope we come out of this disaster with some credit and hopefully some way back to what we once were.
Bobby

Agree2 Disagree2

I would be bitterly disappointed if rangers fans go to away games once back in the SPL, think u can live without us...we will see!

Agree2 Disagree5

Boycotts, marches and threats is that all this club has to offer? Not one ounce of contrition has left even the most fair minded of people feeling that you wont be missed.

Agree6 Disagree1

This will be coming from tic supporters who were doing what exactly oh that's right they were planning boycotts of any clubs that voted to let gers back in spl , well that's fair minded, more like two faced.

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 20:37:59
Don't know if it's been asked but is it not a conflict of interest for Ally being Jamie Ness' agent and a manager trying to compel other players to return ?

Paddy Malarkey

Believable7 Unbelievable1

I'm sure it's against SFA regulations to be a club manager and a players agent.
I'm sure his contract of employment at Ibrox for £20k per week, £1m a year, is exclusive and states he will do no paid work elsewhere.
I'm also sure Rangers forbids its managers from being its players agents.

So Om sure he doesn't represent Janie Ness.

Agree1 Disagree3

03 Jul 2012 20:23:27
Still cant express my anger enough at the likes of lafferty, mcgregor, naismith n davis bailing.
Lets take Davis as an example, the club you grew up supporting offers you a basic of 15k a week, for 3 years you are paid your 15k a week to play week in week out infront of your loyal fans, as a fan yourself nothing could get better.......but then your offered a contract extension n the opportunity to captain your beloved rangers, oh n by the way you'll be pain 25k a week now!!
Fast forward 6 months n after recieving well over 2.5 million in wages n adored by your fans your asked to take a reduced wage to save staff redundancies n in turn help the club out. now you'll still pocket around 6k a week but you'll be doing your club a massive service here.
So no resolution was reached to save the club, the club you claimed to love. But we have a new start, sure we may be in sfl 3 but its still the same fans, the same stadium and a real chance for me to be part of making history. but f**k it, no intae it, i'm off!!!!
I would've given anything to play for rangers and even now i'd do the same to be part of the newco, an opportunity to be part of something that will make history for years to come, to be there at the very start n to win the first trophy for this new club is the stuff of which legends are made. Something money cant buy!!!
I respect the likes of big jig, wallace, hutton ect who have sacraficed certain stability elsewhere, to stay n build this club outa the ruins of rangers. lafferty, davis n co can settle for a mediocre career elsewhere, these other guys i mentioned will be remembered for years n years to come whilst you guys are nothing more than a distant memory.
J1985

Believable9 Unbelievable8

Totally agree, When they decided to desert us, nothing had been decided as to where we would be playing.
The very least they could have done is to report back and then trigger the clauses put into their contract.
They claim to be Rangers men...No Rangers man i know would hurt the club like this.
I've said before, none of them will ever hit the heights they have had at Ibrox.
I agree with Greene that they chased the money. However it is the younger players i'm more angry with as even if we go to 1st Div, this would have been the making of them, for them to become the future of the club, How fkin dare they leave a team like us. They have made a mistake, in a few years they will be back with their tail between their legs playing with the St Mirrens and Motherwells as their progress will have been stunted, and for that we should all laugh, I may sound bitter but what a bunch of ungrateful little erses.
BR

Agree1 Disagree0

Strolled away then ...you might get you chance to play,if you play part-time, many do in 3rd div

Agree1 Disagree1

@1. Yer right mate. McCabe has a hand full of first team games n all of a sudden he fancies his chances in england. Ness struggles to play reguarly due to this ongoing complaint he has, oh n btw we've looked after the boy throughout, but he's off at the first chance he gets. Danny wilson headed for liverpool hoping to make an impact down south, 1 carling cup game being played outa position later n hes off on loan to the lower leagues. wouldn't be surprised if both mccabe n ness went the same way.
J1985

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 20:10:36
Green in talks to try keep us in spl nd if there is any u turn in the vote celtic look cert to gain big money over time with us getting points duduction nd transfer ban• I read about it on twitter on a news page• So for me I would take a third divi nd build our reputation nd our clubs back up nd stronger than before nd stronger than the worst team in the spl that is celtic

Believable2 Unbelievable7

Sir you are a buffoon....and all that is wrong with your club......with supporters like you your club will surely flourish.....JohnnyG

Agree4 Disagree1

Yes,the worst team just won the league by 20 pts(20-10=10 in my book!)so where do you get your ideas?You are just a hate-merchant

Agree2 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 19:46:07
I would not like to see rangers at this moment in time to be playing in spl or div 1 as the nearly all the players have ran off into the night who in the right mind would sign for us at this moment in time

build up from div 3 for me with youth and experienced journymen

Believable6 Unbelievable1

With tens of thousands of supporters paying each week (or season) it won't take long to re-build the squad.

Agree1 Disagree1

03 Jul 2012 19:39:39
enoughs enough now we gotta get behind ally and the team no matter what league we are in give this green guy a chance

Believable12 Unbelievable6

03 Jul 2012 19:31:43
Rangers to start in div 3

sky and espn to half there tv deals

one club to go bust next season in spl

rangers will become stronger

Believable5 Unbelievable9

Really? Might take a few years...........green jhedi

Agree7 Disagree0

Yes, another club might need to go newco. At least they'll know what awaits them by then.

Agree1 Disagree0

The sky will turn green, the sea red, and you will stop taking your medication!

Agree3 Disagree0

God are Dundee going to go bust again sam eold then? as for espn and sky halfing money think you may see changeheart,,, when takes four years at least for NEWCO to get europe etc..... unless they go bust also??

Agree0 Disagree0

How can a new company (football team) enter any of the Scottish league's without 3 years accounts, the rules state that they must be in place before being accepted. Also if Newco is accepted you may find that teams such as Spartans and Cove Rangers, who have been getting their accounts in order for a move to the third division may legally oppose Newco being accepted before them.

Vambo {Ed039's Note - Read it again vambo, they don't need that from a reformed company, airdrie united wouldn't have had 3 years accounts as they were a newco)

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 19:19:03
Motherwell fans vote no to Newco

No to Newco: 542 (82%)
Yes to Newco: 119 (18%)
Votes not returned: 247

Mac2.

Believable5 Unbelievable2

That all the fans they ,their in the s**t pollock jnrs get more fans

Agree1 Disagree0

How can the % total be 100% when 247 votes were not returned? Anywhere else they would have been abstensions.
Should read No - 60%, Yes 19% and abstained - 27%.
908 Motherwell fans and 27% didn't bother.
With all the bold fans say no to the newco it boils down to a handful. Ah well 908 is more than the no to the newco demonstration that was held on Saturday at Hampden organised by CFCPLC fans, when 14 turned up and that was for the free jelly and ice cream.

Agree1 Disagree2

Gee that's some total of Motherwell fans. !!

Niice to see the power of a few hundred booting us in the b****cks.

Good luck to all of you - you'll be next to go under, wait and see.

Agree0 Disagree2

This is true it's on the Motherwell FC website. The thing is the feeling of Scottish society on the issue. Motherwell is a typical central belt west town. It's actually quite Rangers sympathetic and historically employs former Ibrox players in the squad or as managers. The Fir Park social club plays the national anthem at the end of every night and everyone stands to attention.
Given the above 82% of season ticket holders who voted, voted NO to newco. The strength of feeling runs deep and Rangers needs to make amends over many years to come good.

Agree2 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 19:06:29
every one stop saying we can only sign teens cause we can sign older players too , yous are so negitive towards your team makes me quite angry tbh .

Believable2 Unbelievable7

The transfer embargo is at present still in effect so players under the age of 18 are the ONLY players you can sign.

Agree1 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 18:54:09
by by spl and scottish fitba in general.....maybe a good thing ......weathers rotten....players gettin way too much coin.....anyone taken a look at fir park lately....its a swamp....champions league at fir park....ha...deecee

Believable5 Unbelievable7

I take it you will be off? So their is a good point then!..........green jhedi

Agree2 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 18:46:08
Nice to see the lone supporter outside Hampden today.Poster with bulldog and saying 'we bite back'.What an advert for the club.No end to the shame.

Believable11 Unbelievable3

03 Jul 2012 18:38:23
Sitting in the sun in Portugal and have enjoyed the time away from the fiasco. Happened by accident to get sight of a DR today and can't believe what I am reading. What is the point of staying in the SPL with transfer embargo in place. We will be relegated with what we have left. I also read a points deduction so we have no chance.
I would much rather go to div three and work our way up, but do much for the sporting integrity aspect. These
Clubs now want a secret ballot because they don't want to be seen upsetting their fans. The sooner everybody understands that there is no sporting integrity in place, the clubs want to look after themselves. They thought they could stand one season but now it may be four they are petrified.
Unless the situation is that we are in SPL with no more than ten points deduction and able to make signings, the rest will suffer. I understand that most may not like this idea but that is the facts. I know they want to have a kick when we are down but the truth is if they kick too hard they will all suffer.
Sky said happy with Rangers out for a year, so SPL thought they would still be in tv money and are seen to punish Rangers. Not much sporting integrity there then.

However I still don't get what not paying NI and Paye has to do with sporting integrity. This is not a case of buying players we could not afford, this is because Whyte needed a way for administration, nothing more , nothing less.

Believable8 Unbelievable7

Ally got booted out of 4 tournaments and Whyte had to withhold £14.5m PAYE, NI and vat to pay the bills and stop rangers from folding.
This money gave him a sporting advantage over other honest SPL teams who were paying PAYE, NI and Vat. This delivered second place for Rangers who fielded players they couldn't afford. Zero sporting integrity. I'm sure rangers will be stripped of secon place last season.

Agree2 Disagree2

03 Jul 2012 18:31:28
green now resorting to desperation, should have cut and run long ago charlie boy......

Believable11 Unbelievable5

03 Jul 2012 18:15:57
Get david longmuir of s f l at the top table of our game. This guy is so level headed such a good speaker done a great job for s f l the last few years. More importantly he is scottish he does not support any of the old firm and he knows what sport is all about as this guy once qualified for the world indoor bowls championship. Think people at the top of our game are full of blazer's who have never even played a sport or had any interest in sport.

Believable4 Unbelievable4

Football and bowls their so alike eh? Is bowls really a sport? suppose its as much as synchronised swimming I suppose.

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 17:42:13
John Brown: "My plan will put Rangers men in charge of Rangers. The type of people who will not surrender to Peter Lawwell and Celtic the way Green has surrendered to them."

I don't like his language, with words like "surrender". Can't he see this is about negotiations and business?

Believable17 Unbelievable4

Is this guy really what decent newco fans want?"surrendered to Lawell?" Jeeze,he sounds like that idiot Leggat.

Agree7 Disagree1

Brown is a bafoon, and absolute fool, who makes a total @rse of himself every time he opens his mouth.

He is an embarrasment to Rangers.

Why would any investor with the sort of money required to invest in Rangers align themselves with this eejit.

Mac2.

Agree6 Disagree1

Bomber really is coming across like the last person we need at Ibrox going on about Rangers men, well does he think the team he played in should just have been Rangers men?

Because guys like Gazza and Michael Laudrup weren't Rangers men but were ten times the player Brown ever was.

Sober yourself up Bomber and step away before you make an even bigger clown of yourself. Or at least watch Malcolm Murray speak and try and learn how to conduct yourself with some dignity and class.

Agree3 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 17:35:21
Scottish Football League clubs to vote on newco Rangers proposal

03 July 2012 16:56 BST

SFL clubs will return to Hampden to have their final say on the league future of the Rangers newco. Pic: SNS Group
Scottish Football League clubs will vote next Thursday on plans to allow newco Rangers to play in the First Division.

The 30 members of the league met at Hampden on Tuesday to discuss the proposals, which would see Charles Greens new club bypass the bottom two divisions in exchange for a TV rights payment of £1m and the introduction of play-offs.

STV understands the SFL board has ruled a simple majority will be required in the vote. A number of clubs have already indicated they will abstain due to a conflict of interest.

Speaking ahead of the first meeting, Raith Rovers director Turnbull Hutton expressed his anger at non-SPL clubs being "threatened" they would lose vital finance if they didn't approve the plans.

It is not an SFL issue," he said. "Weve been lumbered with this. There are rules we feel they should be followed. They [newco Rangers] should apply for the Third Division.

[We are being] bullied, railroaded and lied to. We are being lied to by the Scottish FA and the SPL. We are being threatened and bullied. It is not football as I know it.

It was a ridiculous document which came out last week whereby the threat was there that if you dont vote for an acceptance into the First Division, a breakaway SPL2 will come along and those who didnt vote wouldnt be invited.

What kind of game are we running here? It is corrupt.

More to follow...

Believable7 Unbelievable1

I say 3rd division no sanctions and get on with it
no more arguing /no more threats /no transfer bans /operate within an agreed budget with sfa sfl .benefits to all wee clubs on the way up.rebild restructure scottish football next season which could if newco performance merits it would reduce time out top league , get some rangers games on sky/espn meantime sfa could divert some of their reserves to ensure sky deal is worth same to clubs while newco catch up . time for arguing /laughin is over lets get on with it before we kill the game for ever tommo

Agree3 Disagree0

There was a general concensus NO today which prompted the need for an official vote on the 12th July. The mood was more negative at the SFA document than positive.
How Rangers could enter the SFL competitions if it went YES with only 10 days to spare is anyone's guess.

Agree0 Disagree0

I've read the SFA proposal and it's quite simply not true in its commercial findings for each Rangers model.
All the restructuring could be done with Rangers in div3. Play offs, pyramid system, etc..... I suspect play offs are so rangers get a one game chance at promotion if they don't win but come second or third.... And we all know the honest mistakes and wee bits of luck u can get in one match!

Agree1 Disagree0

There is an approved procedure for al NewCos applying to enter the SFL and that is to apply for entry to Div3.

Agree2 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 17:03:50
Ed all this talk of Green getting the season ticket money, but does he get the money from all the merchandise that is sold like the new rangers strips? Therefore is this money being used to pay the players right now and not his consortium? {Ed039's Note - I think the strip sales are part of the asset transfer, but the old deal was complicated so I dont know how much Rangers actually get from shirt sales)

Believable1 Unbelievable3

Just spent £300 this afternoon in JD sports.
There was plenty Celtic stuff there but zero Rangers gear.
Has the 5 star gear been withdrawn? Or just sold out?

Agree0 Disagree6

03 Jul 2012 17:01:28
Why would green suggest all these sanctions! We will be lucky to avoid relegation and therefore end up in sfl for following season any way! Far better to to take our medicine and work back up!

Believable18 Unbelievable0

Would it not be better for us in the long turn that's why he is thinking a few years time we could be back where we belong on top off scottish football i see where you are coming from why put us in admin if we need to pay wat is ood thats a bit p*** we should not get fined if we pay our debts one p****ed off bear

Agree1 Disagree4

03 Jul 2012 17:01:16
STV "Charles Green says fans have to listen to the economics of “financial meltdown for the whole world” as the SPL prepares to vote on allowing newco Rangers in or out of the top league."

Right, so the whole world will crumble if newco Rangers aren't allowed in the SPL. Really. CG is either desperate or bonkers.

Am I the only onw here who thinks the debate should be about football? The question is: Is newco Rangers good enough to play in the SPL with the punishments that have been discussed? I personally think yes, so surely that's the win-win scenario?

McWulf

Believable0 Unbelievable8

Green's last dance to increase the value of Gers when he sells in 5-10 months.
He has to deliver a profit for his investors and himself of a ROI min 100%.
Why should SPL chairmen deliver these guys millions?

Agree1 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 16:56:18
16 of the 30 SFL clubs are needed to vote newco Rangers into Div 1.

Novote expected today. Members could agree to call EGM though which would take place next week.


Source: BBC {Ed039's Note - No vote could take place today, the SFA must give 5 working days notice to call the EGM required to pass such a vote)

Believable1 Unbelievable0

The vote aint today why post utter bull ??
plz explain

Agree2 Disagree0

12th July. Simple majority vote.
16 votes from 30 needed. Abstentions bad for newco. 8 vote NO already.

Timmy Troll.

Agree3 Disagree0

Time to move on, if decisions cannot be made today, reconvene tomorrow. Too many unnecessary delays.

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 16:30:36
A question to all our visiting fans who come on to wish us well and support us in our time of need

Would this satisfy your bloodlust

SPL vote to transfer PLC share to LTD
SPL punish rangers with deduction of points for last season and we are relegated to divsion 1 in place of dunfermline

I think that resolves all issues of how to issue a punishment, how to get us into division 1 and the who stays up

JG

Believable5 Unbelievable10

No.The share should not be transferable,and the newco should start by applying to division three. They have not got a licence yet!

Agree7 Disagree3

You can't be relegated as you are about to be liquidated FFS.

OldCo will be expelled from SPL and Newco applies for entry to SFL. It's not complicated! It's not optional

Agree8 Disagree4

You didn't help your cause by framing this as "bloodlust".

It's about what is costs Rangers to lose its "bad history" and keep its "good history". There is no formula, unfortunately, so everyone is trying to work out what's best for all and for the longer term. Remember it might happen to any of them sometime also.

Agree0 Disagree0

Agreed. Division 3 is the only decent outcome. Too much to put this kind of
pressure on the SFa clubs.
No to SPL and division one. The only way is to work our way back up.

Agree3 Disagree0

Dear JG and other Newco fans,

I'm a Dundee United fan, but am among the minority in my family as they are mostly Bears!

You use the word bloodlust, however I 'bear' no ill will towards the NewCo and am in no way trying to compound things for Rangers fans. Now if it was Celtic.. well, that's another story ;-)

I feel that the phoenix that rises from the OldCo ashes should apply to join the SFL along with other teams i.e Spartans, Gala Faridean etc, where each of these teams would present their case to the SFL.

The new company should demonstrate beyond doubt that they can harness the massive OldCo fanbase, and along with the assets they have purchased, provide a transparent plan of how the NewCo can and will be a positive addition to Scottish Football.

The important word in the last sentence is 'Scottish'. If I was on the SFL panel deciding who should get the berth now available in the 3rd Division, I would expect that club to demonstrate their vision for a modern 'Scottish' club.

As those who have already commented on your post have stated, OldCo/NewCo fans need to accept they are not being punished. Your OldCo has been liquidated and as such you are hoping to join the Scottish League setup. The NewCo have the same options that was available to Livingston and Gretna when they were liquidated.

To my mind, the existing rules must be 'followed'!

There are the obvious financial implications for the whole of Scottish Football should the NewCo be absent from the top flight for 3 years+. My club is one of those likely to be severely affected, but that's a price I am willing to pay. Lower quality football, season ticket price increase, but built on a league setup that treats every club as an *equal*.

The standard of our game and the clubs (I hope that includes the NewCo!) making up our leagues will move towards to their natural level. A level that can be built on for the future.

Arab Robb.

Agree1 Disagree1

Ok thanks for the input - Arab Robb the reason l used the word bloodlust is because, when i see football supporters say they would rather see their own clubs go to the wall rather than have rangers in the SPL then they have some serious hate issues going on

JG

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 16:19:26
So we have a meeting of the SPL tomorrow to vote Newco/Rangers in or out and we all know what the decision will be given the opinions offered before a meeting actually take place.Might be a good idea in future just to ask for all decisons to be reached via the public domaine prior to any meeting and save all the costs involved of actually convening a meeting.
No that would be too sensible bit like HMRC who we are all led to believe by Duff and Phelps might agree to a CVA but come the week leading up to the decision HMRC all of a sudden tell us that it is not their policy to go down this route. Again we are taken as mugs Duff and Phelps continue to rake in money week after week when it seriously must be questioned why HMRC never thought to mention this way back in February and despite the fact it would have meant Liquidation the picture would have been clearer months ago and Duff and Phelps would not have bled the same level of money out of the sorry situation. There is something seriously wrong when the Tax man states he would never enter into this type of CVA yet Duff and Phelps continue to suggest they might. Whats the chance of a spokesman from either explaining this?

Believable4 Unbelievable2

Blinkered,lots of celtic fans pointed out that the HMRC website explained they would not accept a CVA from a company with a bad tax payment record.

Agree7 Disagree4

With decent odds I'd put money on Rangers playing in the SPL next season. Fickle lot these club chairmen.

Agree0 Disagree3

HMRC's position has been clear for the past 6 years. They will not provide escape routes for tax evasion. Duff & Phelps should/must have known this ?

Agree1 Disagree0

Well here's the dilemma HMRC supposedly Hinted that it would be agreeable to cva in talks with duff and duffer but then opted to decline, now my only slight problem is we have still not heard the outcome of the tax tribunal, and the EBT inquiry at the SPL has also been postponed so it leaves us none the wiser, unfortunately the witch might well be burnt at the stake ,this could only happen in Scotland, you guys out there that will no doubt come back with your retorts , but see at the end of the day it's you guys that could quite easily put the nail in Scottish footballs coffin,and the sad thing is it could have been avoided if the media had not wanted to outdo each other, as someone said recently the things that are said don't need to be true but if they are repeated enough times then they are conceived to be true ie propaganda and the media have done this great, so we will just have to wait and see how this pan's out

Agree1 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 15:22:10
Who is that person standing outside Hampden representing?
"Ranger bite back"
We don't have any teeth ya bampot What chance have we got of getting any support from other clubs, When you have idiots like that wearing our team colours making stupid threats. He might be a lone nutter but will be seen to be speaking on our behalf.
Jake.

Believable11 Unbelievable2

If hes so interested in showing his support for Rangers perhaps he could have dug a little deeper into his pockets and bought an up to date Rangers top...every little helps.

Agree5 Disagree1

Jake, calm down i think he will be seen for the nutter he is a not a representative of the bears
i doubt if he will sway the vote one way or the other and remember the thing that makes our country great, you may be a nutter but you still have the right to freedom of speech

JG

JG

Agree4 Disagree3

03 Jul 2012 15:48:15
After tomorrow no matter what the outcome of the vote. I think that its time to go to one organisation running the whole of scottish football and get people in who know the rules and who have the balls to make a decision and stick to it. This situation is not fair on every club in scotland as this should have been dealt with by the people who run our game of football yes game of football because thats what we should be bothered about is football not how big or how small any one club are

Believable4 Unbelievable0

03 Jul 2012 15:45:57
up to 6 spl teams at risk if rangers are demoted. stewart regan

Believable6 Unbelievable7

I am sick of this if teams cant survive without celtic or sevco then they should not be in the league

Agree7 Disagree3

@1 thats the fn problem, they wont be for much longer, your not happy with wanting us gone now you want more teams gone (sporting of you) still it would give you a better chance of winning the treble so no harm done there then

JG

Agree6 Disagree5

U budget with the income u have not what u might have if a team cant run on its own steam then it should not run full stop u cant run a team saying well i might get money off that team this team we might get money from cup run. thats a sorry way 2 run a team u dont here teams in 1 2 3 divions saying that u run your club with what u have

Agree0 Disagree0

@1 when will realise what is about to happen, clubs have stated publicly they will suffer. St Mirren/ Dundee United no signings possible redundancies, Motherwell administration.
So, why not take off your green tinted glasses and see what is actually happening.
Yes, Rangers are to blame but your pathetic attitude just compounds the state scottish football is in.
And by the way if you find it difficult let me type it for you, RANGERS.

Agree1 Disagree1

@JG;What a stupid response.The poster is correct,if clubs are being badly run they will have difficulties.They will just have to cut back.simple.This scaremongering is ridiculous. green jhedi

Agree3 Disagree0

@4:

Why would anyone find it difficult to type RANGERS.

Hoopey67

Agree0 Disagree0

@5 they have publicly stated they may go into administration, people will be made redundant and they cant afford to sign anyone. Where does that leave the SPL, get real and put a business head on to look at this whole sorry state.
You were shouting from the rooftops about sporting integrity does that allow for other clubs to go bust because of the actions of two individuals?
Rangers should be punished but now it seems this is to appease all the people who have nothing but hatred for the club which is now evident.
By the way your own chairman is keeping very quiet, any ideas why???

Agree1 Disagree1

@5 Scaremongering? you lot were scaremongering with threats to all the clubs about fan bhoycotts.
Clubs in the splc run their budgets tightly already, they have little spare cash and have players on long term contracts based on projected revenue including the TV deals and visits by CFCPLC and the oldco/newco fans. These will have to be reviewed.
They have to try and pay their players the best wages they can otherwise the players are off. If the players leave or they dont sign anyone there is the chance of relegation, which could be a case of no return as crowds would fall and their revenue also if relegated.
The 10 other clubs in the SPL now have the upper hand regards pushing new rules through, inclusive of share of the gate monies and TV revenue.
These figures of up to 6 clubs being at risk will only highlight the case for them to try and get more revenue, TV or gates or both? Remember there is now an Edinburgh derby and a Dundee derby(taking it Dundee are promoted) for SKY to replace the previous Glasgow derby.
I really do hope RFC go to the 3rd div as all the blame cannot be attached to a newco starting in div 3 and secure a TV deal for away matches. Of course CFCPLC don't need their TV revenue, but other clubs in the SPLC do as it accounts for up to 30% of their revenue.
CFCPLC because of their size will now be the main PLC that the other 11 clubs in the SPLC will want to hit financially.
There is no scaremongering there, just plain commonsense. There is no integrity involved when each club is looking after number 1.

Agree0 Disagree1

03 Jul 2012 15:38:18
From an interested neutral

I think we are in agreement that Rangers deserve to be punished. I think we are all in agreement that there are financial implications of the relegation of Rangers to either 1 or 3, the only thing open to debate is the severity.

Ive heard many saying, "not a problem! clubs will cut their cloth accordingly, sporting integrity is paramount, no to newco!" etc etc. However, there is a rather large price to pay for this position, the jobs of some of those working for clubs in the various leagues.

So, a quick question to those on the no to newco bandwagon. Are you happy to sacrifice the jobs of ordinary folks on the altar of your 'sporting integrity' as rest assured there will be job cuts as many clubs frantically cut costs.

Believable13 Unbelievable4

A lot more jobs have been put at risk by Rangers' deliberate policy of evading tax & NI so let's not have this santimonious nonsence, eh?

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 15:18:08
if rangers get back in to spl which of the players who left will regret they had not left ? {Ed039's Note - None, they have the opportunity to resurrect their careers and earn a good payday)

Believable1 Unbelievable3

If CG is right, they haven't left anyway. Might be interesting and there could be some twists yet.

Agree1 Disagree4

Let's be honest.

If they do get back in its just papering over the cracks,if rangers don't finished 2nd or don't have half a decent team then the 'old firm' games won't intrest sky which in turn will offer us even less money ?

Lenny

Agree3 Disagree2

03 Jul 2012 15:12:37
At last a public apology from someone at rfc, bit late but an apology all the same, had someone done this 4 or 5 months ago this all would have been different, very little sympathy left for ibrox town/city/united whatever we will be next season.

Believable5 Unbelievable6

Its all 2 late so how r sevco going 2 pay the 160.000 fine the money owed 2 hearts the money owed 2 rapid and all other football debts and sevco r willing 2 accept the transfer ban this smells a bit fishy

Agree3 Disagree3

This u turn from green has nothing 2 do with helping scottish football this is all 2 do with green knowing sevco wont survive if they r put into 3rd

Agree3 Disagree2

S#it it only needed someone to say the wee magic word and it would all have been different, all the pent up hatred directed towards us would not have happened, our CVA would have been accepted no financial problems, everybody would have been offering us support through our time of need, damn we missed that chance

do you have the munchies by any chance?

JG

Agree5 Disagree1

03 Jul 2012 14:57:25
Barry Ferguson has been talking to
the Evening Times. Wish somebody
would tell him to button it . JK

Believable5 Unbelievable6

03 Jul 2012 14:54:06
Charles green has now resorted to the begging bowl, a word in your ear charles, it has got to be the 3rd div. for two massive reasons, 1-any new club must start from the bottom or we are all wasting our time and money, 2-let the smaller spl clubs resort to their wee club syndrome when they go bust all because they listned to their fans who only turn up for the big games, they have been living off the old firm for many years and now they have bit the hand that feeds let them rot, along with the rest of the sfl clubs who have taken the high moral ground. watp.......

Believable6 Unbelievable6

What a bitter rant.let's wait and see just how many clubs go bust.

Agree6 Disagree6

03 Jul 2012 14:48:20
Ok im firstly devastated for the fans of rangers football club who have been nothing but fantastic in these bad times. I want to ask peoples veiws on where it all went wrong. Looking back at the history of Rangers, the period when Dick Advocat was in charge. Do you think this period is vital in reagrds to your financial situation now?

Sam Adzii JFT96

Believable5 Unbelievable5

03 Jul 2012 14:47:32
Mr green needs listen to rangers fans first and foremost, we don't want favours, we want 3rd division.

Believable9 Unbelievable1

I dont want third division, why should I, i want my team to play at the highest level and whether we like it or not that is the SPL
I cant believe how many supporters actually want to go to 3rd division, do you think it is going to be a wee romantic journey or what, it is going to be hell and could cause further irreparable damage to the rangers being stuck in the wilderness of football for years and put financial constraints on rebuilding the club. need to take a reality check fellow bears, if your motives are to ram it right up other spl teams that is cutting off our nose to spite our face

JG

JG

Agree4 Disagree8

@JG: Damage to rangers? Are you mad,rangers are being liquidated.The damage has been done. green jhedi

Agree1 Disagree1

Mr green has to loby to get rangers into the highest league he can thats his job he has investers to please me i would go to the third not to punish any clubs but because i feel we have done wrong and need to pay the price and only then can we at least say we took our punishment BUT our punishment is not in our hands its in the hands of the member clubs and i await and will accept whatever punishment they hand out it cant come from the fans it has to come from the chairmen they are the only ones that truely know the state of their own clubs and by the way why has the sfa waited all this time before saying they would block any entry of the newcoo into the spl they have allowed all this bloodlust over weeks and weeks the damage this has done between supporters will take years to heal if it ever dose ,, cooperboy

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 14:36:56
Direct from an aquantence fo greens, he is campaigining for SPL re-instatement vigoriously as he wants to sell the club on as an SPL club, hence why he is willing to accept all sanctions imposed by the SFA. if Newco are put in division 3 or even in div 1 but fail to get promoted then he is shutting up shop, selling the stadium and murray park to the highest bidded with the clubs logo and brand merchandise being donated to a rangers fans group.

spl and sfl and sfa are putting across that its the long term future of scottish football that they are looking out for, butpeople need to realise whichever division rangers (newco ) end up in they will struggle to adapt and win it....i wonder how long the fans and players will stay loyal when celtic are playing european football midweek while newco are travelling to brechin on a wet winters night.

Believable2 Unbelievable4

Utter rubbish.The logo has gone,it cant be used.and so has the brand rangers.

Agree4 Disagree6

Celtic European football winter no m8 that does ring any bells.Another bundle of laughs for us bears in a year of turmoil.

Agree2 Disagree2

@1
Your talking utter rubbish
I've had the misfortune of being in a company liquidated
The new company had the same logo and the same customers staff used the same overalls and the same paperwork

Agree4 Disagree3

@3; Well you are lying or the company were not liquidated.Read the rules,you cannot operate in a style to similar to the liquidated company.

Agree0 Disagree0

Year of turmoil, mate i think youll find it will be 5 years of turmoil at least.

even if celtic dont make it past winter we will still have min of 6 european games whil the newco head to cowdenbeath. how loyal the hounds be when there team is getting kicked up and down semi proffesional pitches on a weekly basis.

Agree0 Disagree1

@5. Celtic won't make it past August in Europe, never mind mid-winter.

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 13:36:24
At last an apology.Too little too late.Wonder if anything to do with forthcoming vote?If it happened in Feb things might be different. {Ed039's Note - Too little, too late, so why have there been so many people on here as long ago as yesterday demanding an apology? Cant win)

Believable5 Unbelievable1

Eh, ED, Apologies should not have to be demanded, They should be offered without prompt by wrong doers, as soon as it is realised they made the wrong decision, statement or deed. Not forced out of someone in a lame attempt at showing remorse in order to carry favour.
Jake {Ed039's Note - Thats fair enough and a good point, but the point I am making is there are so many people on here saying, why has there been no apology, when is there going to be an apology, and now one has been made it is too little too late, dont forget this guy has only been in office a few weeks and has alot of pressing matters, the people responsible should have been making this statement, but there is very little chance of that happening)

Agree4 Disagree0

Ed ,It's the TIMING of the apology--not last month,last week,not next week but TODAY.That's why there are people commenting now.You say they can't win but it could have happened months ago.

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 13:26:33
Honesty!

Raith director: 'We are being bullied and the Scottish game is corrupt'

03 July 2012 12:30 BST
Raith Rovers director Turnbull Hutton says clubs in the Scottish Football League are being lied to, bullied and threatened by the Scottish FA and Scottish Premier League to accept a newco Rangers into the First Division.

Hutton says the attempts to force teams to bypass a formal application process for Charles Green's company are "corrupt", following threats that finances from the SPL would be cut off and a breakaway league formed.

It is not an SFL issue, he said. Weve been lumbered with this. There are rules we feel they should be followed. They [newco Rangers] should apply for the Third Division.

[We are being] bullied, railroaded and lied to. We are being lied to by the Scottish FA and the SPL. We are being threatened and bullied. It is not football as I know it.

It was a ridiculous document which came out last week whereby the threat was there that if you dont vote for an acceptance into the First Division, a breakaway SPL2 will come along and those who didnt vote wouldnt be invited.

What kind of game are we running here? It is corrupt.

When asked if he agreed with the SFLs assertion that Sccottish football would face financial meltdown without Rangers, he replied: I dont believe that.

The 30 member clubs of the SFL are meeting at Hampden on Tuesday to discuss proposals which would see Charles Greens newco parachuted into the First Division, as opposed to applying to enter at Third Division level.

A presentation sent out by the league to its members last week warned £16m could be wiped out from the Scottish game if Rangers had to play in the bottom tier.

It promised an additional £1m would be divided amongst clubs in TV money if the club were to participate in the First Division, with play-offs and a change to financial distribution also proposed.

Believable4 Unbelievable0

03 Jul 2012 13:20:57
Ed, or anyone - do you know if it is a secret ballot tomorrow or will it be announced who were the yeah and the nae

JG {Ed039's Note - It has been reported that it may change to a secret ballot instead of a show of hands)

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Why? more threats to be dished up if newco dont get what they want? {Ed039's Note - No, because they other chairmen have issues of the longevity of their clubs, therefore it is their own fans that they will be hiding from, although I dont think it will make any difference. Does everything have to come down to Rangers, these clubs have their own problems you know?)

Agree0 Disagree0

@1 get aff your high horse, i only asked a question

JG

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 12:44:45
Ed - Can you explain what income sources Newco has at present? {Ed039's Note - Very little, it has been difficult to sell season tickets with the uncertainty of the club and sponsors wont be banging down the doors to throw money at the club and obviously without knowing which division RFC might or might not end up in there is no TV income)

Believable2 Unbelievable0

It would be interesting to see what terms are being offered to those opting to sign for Newco! {Ed039's Note - For players under contract to the oldco it would be the previous terms and conditions of their old contract)

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 12:21:15
Ed, 2 questions please, u seem a fair sort, knowledgeable and intelligent. I respect your views.
1. Do you think fielding EBT players, paid offshore and illegally registered is a form of match fixing?
2. Do you think Rangers should be allowed in the SPL or go to Div1 or Div3.

Thanks for your opinion on the 'history' question yesterday. {Ed039's Note - Answers and they are only my opinion (1) i dont think it is a form of match fixing, it was a very poorly advised tax avoidance scheme which has become the route cause of the shambles that Scottish football finds itself in BUT no doubt it did add an unfair advantage to RFC in the sense that they signed players that ordinarily they couldnt afford. (2) It depends on your stance, I dont care what people say, Rangers the brand in whatever shape or form they emerge in next season is a big draw, and it has been widely reported that financial hardship other clubs are going to find themselves in if it does not go towards helping the TV deals (again not the fault of these teams, the fault lies with Rangers), I feel if there was no financial implications on others then Rangers should automatically go to SFL 3, but I dont think this will happen)

Believable1 Unbelievable1

03 Jul 2012 13:52:56
Barry Ferguson has joined the latest mantra, "be careful what you wish for." He is talking of Division 3 up to a point. Isn't this the wish of a large number of Rangers fans? I read as high as 80%. From the Rangers supports point of view this breaks up into two categories, those wishing for a clean slate, an appreciation that in no way can a club be parachuted and neither asking for nor seeking favour in whatever decision is made. They see the bigger picture and know full well anything short of a consistent approach similar to Livingston will be a cop out that Rangers fans will have to endure criticism for years to come. The other part of the Division 3 brigade within Ibrox, are of the screw you mentality, presuming that meltdown will occur to teams in the SPL and elsewhere. Should it be Division 3, what do Rangers return to when finally reaching the SPL then? Very forward thinking that bunch. The rest of Scottish football fans leaning towards Division 3, possibly have two camps also, those desperate for a kick at Rangers/the old firm, they'd be similarly minded if it was Celtic too. And the second faction of what I'm one, simply want consistency and the closest example in Scottish football to date is Livingston.

Believable1 Unbelievable0

03 Jul 2012 13:16:55
Ibrox chairman Malcolm Murray released a statement
"All of Scottish football is now having to live with the consequences and every true Rangers fan will consider it a matter of deep regret that events at our club in the past have been the root cause of an extremely difficult time for Scottish football.
"We want to rebuild Rangers but we also want to ensure the club plays a role that is beneficial to Scottish football, the Scottish economy and Scottish life in general."
And then you get idiots coming out with the below statement. I agree with Murray and what he is saying. There are many genuine rangers supporters that feel it is only right that they go to div 3 but they are overlooked when you get idiots coming out with this tripe about boycotting games. And you wonder why people are against Rangers.
02 Jul 2012 23:38:04
Fellow bears I suggest when we get back to spl all fans and fans groups get together and agree to take only 200 to away matches as this would cost clubs more than wat they would receive in gate receipts as they would have to provide policing, section of stand, catering etc...just a thought? What yous think?

Ian

Believable10 Unbelievable7

Lets start in the third the rest are crapping them selves now

Agree3 Disagree3

You really are a idiot pal your blaming all the spl clubs for voting against you and trying to get back at them, only one set of people are to blame and it's your own club so deal wi it and man up you sound like a 2 year old

Agree3 Disagree2

Well said mate. I slaughtered that comment earlier. Now that Malcolm Murray has made an apology I think roads should, and will, be made to try and resolve this sensibly.

I am a Celtic fan and am sick of the bile being spouted about this. I don't know any Gers fan that has benefitted financially from this. Some fans are talking as if you mugged their granny.

A rich sneaky b**tard did a few dirties in your name ... it wisnae you, but any good fan would accept a level of punishment. Any good opposition fan would accept it and move on (There, but for the grace of god, goes I)

Don't know what the wee clubs are moaning about anyway, the OF finish 25+ points ahead of them in a bad year. If SDM's actions affected any team it was Celtic and I think we've behaved quite well recently (probably just jinxed it). You're always worried that some idiot will spout pish and set off the mental minority.

Tossing Rangers out of the game for years is stupid. We should all try to work together to get some decent fitba on the park.

Anyway, best of luck mate.

Shug

Agree6 Disagree3

Shug

Best post I've ever read on here....a man who can see through the bile....well said !!

Agree2 Disagree1

03 Jul 2012 13:16:46
Integrity and Football now there's an oxymoron if ever there was one. Football is the only sport I can think of where players openly cheat to get penalties and fouls or to get opponents sent off. Yet we are reminded every day that Rangers have to be punished to maintain " integrity" .As a life long Gers fan I understand the previous regimes have done wrong but what have we the fans done to be kicked , kicked and kicked again by everybody and anybody and wants to take a shot at us.

Believable12 Unbelievable7

Ah the old Integrity eh, you can see it everywhere in society cant you, I mean you only needed to look at Bankers,Politicians,Celebrities,Footballers,ect.
we live in the perfect world according to some.

Agree4 Disagree2

THE SAME CAN BE SAID FOR MANY EMPLOYEES OF MANY COMPANIES THAT GET PUNISHED WHEN THINGS GO WRONG THAT THEY CANT AND DONT CONTROL.

IAN

Agree2 Disagree1

A great post !! Not for the content but for the fact that a SEVCO fan can understand the word OXYMORON and utilise it in a constructive way ! Well done, Sir ! Wish there were more like you !

Agree3 Disagree0

The powers that be cannot possibly go easy on rogue clubs because of how fans feel. That's just being silly.

Agree0 Disagree2

03 Jul 2012 13:07:07
Too little too late? And only with voting imminent?

Rangers: Malcolm Murray issues apology from club
03 July 12 12:42

Chairman Malcolm Murray has issued an apology on behalf of Rangers for the "distress, disruption and difficulty inflicted on the football community".
"We are acutely aware that events at our club, brought about by people who are no longer here, have triggered a crisis in Scottish football," he said.
"Ally McCoist, the staff and players have nothing to apologise for.
"But the club needs to make an apology. It is only right that someone expresses our sorrow and regret."
Rangers, champions of Scotland a record 54 times, lost their Scottish Premier League place when the old company was consigned to liquidation last month.
A Charles Green-led consortium is reforming the club, having purchased the assets.
And Scotland's football authorities are busy debating where the Rangers newco should play next season.
With SPL clubs ready to reject a top-flight application from the newco on Wednesday, Scottish Football League clubs are discussing a proposal that would see Rangers admitted to the First Division.
Murray's statement continued: "On behalf of the new board of directors, I apologise unreservedly to all for the distress, disruption and difficulty inflicted on the football community, caused entirely by the actions of people who failed miserably to act responsibly during their stewardship of Rangers.
"All of Scottish football is now having to live with the consequences of that behaviour and every true Rangers fan will consider it a matter of deep regret that events at our club in the past have been the root cause of an extremely difficult time for Scottish football.
"The people who are now running Rangers Football Club want the club to move forward but we cannot do so until we have recognised how damaging to football the crisis at our club has been.
"We want to rebuild Rangers but we also want to ensure the club plays a role that is beneficial to Scottish football, the Scottish economy and Scottish life in general."

Believable2 Unbelievable0

Scottish economy there is a laugh just pay your taxes and the Scottish economy will be fine

hail hail

Marco1888 {Ed039's Note - You think the tax that Rangers have avoided over the years would mean the Scottish economy would be fine, there wouldnt be a recession? Marco you have come out with some rubbish on this page but this has got to be the worst. How much tax do you think it was? Was it billions?)

Agree1 Disagree0

It's never to late, and these people were not to blame, so well done I say.

Agree1 Disagree0

Hi marco you carry on sewing mail bags with your singer sewing machine ,or have they provided you with an electric one now ? doug t.s.o ps.the economy is at stake ,your not working fast enough thats why a 1st class stamp has went up to 60p

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 12:52:01
green is trying to put a secreat deal together so we remain in spl but it says transfer ban will stand well am afraid with our squad we will strugle anyway so whats the point he was just saying yesterday that mccoist would be backed in the transfer market now he is trying do a deal where transfer ban stands mr green u need grow a pair and tell the fans the truth

Believable4 Unbelievable0

03 Jul 2012 12:35:06
Does any one know what would happen if lord hodge rules there is a conflict of intrest with duff and duffer?

Believable3 Unbelievable0

Surely if there is a clash of interest the whole admin process would be null and void and would need to be started all over again cant see it though would be interesting to find out who would come out the woodwork

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 11:53:45
On tomorrows SPL vote, shouldn't we do an Ayr Utd? and abstain from voting on the grounds of conflict of interest?

Believable12 Unbelievable1

No, why would we want to do that, if we are entitiled to vote, as we obvioulsy are, then vote,

JG

Agree3 Disagree2

03 Jul 2012 11:52:13
How long you boys been in administration for? early feb if i recall, so by the end of the month it will be the thick end of 6 months in limbo..... but nothing from the so called fans apart from hot air, had it been any other sfa team the fan base would have raised money, serious money to keep them afloat, RFC have a massive fan base but only raised a couple of hundred thousand. i know you are up to your necks in debt but the silence is deafening (apart from the we will have our revenge on all of you) band. come on action is never too late.

Believable8 Unbelievable8

Aye and well all raise money for it not to be seen again thats robbery. it would have been different if the people who were in charge were trustworthy,

Agree3 Disagree0

In Admin in Feb and end of June it has been 6 mths, very good, no wonder by your etsimations all the other clubs would have raised serious money.
Different page you've been reading if you think we are all saying ' aaaargh! we will have our revenge on all of you' haven't seen anything like that.
So why don't you shut down your mum's laptop, put it back and get out of your mum's clothes and heels before she finds out again. {Ed039's Note - Strange)

Agree0 Disagree1

Demonstrating a sheer dislike for Rangers fans, grow up. Making generalizations like you are all up to your knees in debt, who are you to make such a comment? Why was this even posted this isn't banter is it?

Agree0 Disagree0

Give it a rest. You have been following this story avidly like the fans of all the other clubs since Feb.... And yet you are asking this question now. If you are so concerned about Rangers why don't you dig deep and help them out!

Agree0 Disagree1

Wanna invest in Barclays bank all SPL and SFL fans ?...now u know how we feel!!

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 11:44:15
just off the phone to the ticket office about my direct debit for season ticket , nothing will done just or no money will be taken from bank account till the decision is made which league division we will be in doug t.s.o

Believable1 Unbelievable3

I see someone doesnt agree with me ,well phone them 0871 702 1972 ,thats the info i got from english girl on the staff ,by the way my seat is gf2 row s ,i made the call at 1130am today doug t.s.o {Ed039's Note - Doug ignore the agree and disagree buttons mate, they are a pain the jaxie)

Agree0 Disagree3

03 Jul 2012 11:09:47
i know rangers are in a mess the now but it is going to get sorted one way or another
and with all these players leaving who i dont blame but one or two years from now im gona look back and see who actually went on to better things
there isnt many players who have left rangers or even celtic over the years who have achieved more or better,you do have the odd player like adam larson and van bronkhurst but not many more,i think there may be a few players saying in one years time why did i not stay and be even more loved with the gers fans
watp forever

Believable4 Unbelievable6

Rangers are dead and gone. forget things getting sorted. you are going to support sevco the newco. now grow up and accept this

Agree7 Disagree9

Nonsense, dozens of Celtic players went to English premiership or Europe and became legends there..
Pierre Van Hoidonk, Paulo di Canio, John Collins to Monacco, Gattusso to Italy and champions league victory, ..... Aussie striker at Celtic, many many...

Agree1 Disagree0

Don't include Celtic players in your list.Pleany(too many to name)went on to greater things.Keep to your own history

Agree1 Disagree0

The club never dies you accept it,rangers football club will be playing in scottish football next year,the business side has died not the club

Agree2 Disagree3

OP Rubbish.Lots of players left for bigger clubs ,England and abroad---too many Celtic players to name.

Agree2 Disagree1

Oh my! How you are going to choke on those words and pretty soon I'd imagine.

Agree1 Disagree1

03 Jul 2012 10:05:35
As a Celtic fan id like to thank SDM/white. If it wasn't for their mess id have to get on with supporting my own team.

Believable4 Unbelievable3

No rangers games this season and ur tickets went up in price ,lawell's conned you's

Agree5 Disagree1

And no new players in just out celtic will run away with spl but there average team will suffer the good players celtic have will leave to play in better leauges

Agree1 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 09:44:23
Well we will soon see if its all a sham, as I suspect it is. All the public opinions from clubs stating their intent to kick us out. Yet if we are to believe the papers there are secret discussions going on to keep us in.

I suspected bullsh!t being spewed from these clubs to keep their fans appeased with the continued bloodlust.

Punish us yet save the smaller clubs from going under? I for one would vote against such a move. For me Division 3 is THE only answer. If Scottish Football suffers for it then so be it.

GDog
RTID

Believable13 Unbelievable7

SEVCO Scotland are not in anything at present to be kicked out of . They also don't meet the qualifying criteria for admittance to any level of the SFL . They will have to present three continous year's audited accounts in order to be considered for any vacancy that may arise .You surely don't expect SFL to ignore their own rules to give any club preferential treatment , do you ? To me , it looks like SPL with years of sanctions or three years Junior football to generate the required accounts then application to join SFL - minimum six years out of SPL .An alternative would be to buy one of the clubs that are apparently guaranteed to go to the wall due to financial problems caused by TRFC's demise and rebrand(Clydebank/Airdrie United scenario). SEVCO are sticklers for the rules so the authorities will have to apply them to the letter or risk being dragged to the courts again and incur further wrath of FIFA and UEFA .

Paddy Malarkey

Agree0 Disagree1

Pity no one had asked you to sort things out at the beginning of this fiasco...look at all the cost and time that would have been saved !!

Agree0 Disagree0

03 Jul 2012 09:19:21
Are the wheels already grinding to a halt on the sporting integrity train as they tried to railroad rangers out of the SPL. I cant believe Green is even thinking about accepting terms to clubs who are thinking about a u-turn on kicking Rangers out of the SPL, only because now they realise its their clubs that may face extinction. This has been scenario Rangers supporters have had to endure for the last few weeks. We would have to agree to a six point plan that includes a points deduction, the transfer embargo stays, and they two are enough to kill any chance of Rangers being competitive. We have already lost most of our team and wouldnt be allowed to replace them, only 13 players turned up for training first day. We are out of Europe for three years but our gate money is to help other teams that are in the various competitions in Europe, some of the very teams that have been battering the Rangers naughty boy for weeks. Why dont they give us clarity we all know the answer but they wont come out and say it. We hate you, we dont want you ever having a chance of winning anything, we would like to continually kick you in the teeth, but can we still have the money you will generate. The bullied become the bullies. Charles Green should tell them to go forth a multiply. If he does that I for one will be backing him. It may be a totally different SPL we find ourselves in if we move up from third, and I for one will laugh.

Believable10 Unbelievable5

03 Jul 2012 08:34:26
Will anyone be surprised if there is no decisive outcome or the vote is postponed on the 4th July?

JG

Believable12 Unbelievable7

03 Jul 2012 08:34:07
If Rangers have to accept a transer ban then we will have 2 subs all of next season.

And go without injuries all season.

Believable9 Unbelievable1

That's why rangers should go to sfl 3 , I would not be happy accepting those penalties. If green goes with those penalties I will not be re-newing my season ticket .

Agree4 Disagree0

OP this was our squad last season, think we could get 11 plus some subs out of this even counting out those who have gone. If there is no decent young talent among that lot then we need to ask WHY?

RANGERS SQUAD: GOALKEEPERS
•Allan Mcgregor •Neil Alexander •Scott Gallacher •Grant Adam •Alan Smith •Sam George

RANGERS SQUAD: DEFENDERS
•Dorin Goian •Kirk Broadfoot •Sasa Papac •Lee Wallace •Steven Whittaker •Carlos Bocanegra •Kyle Bartley •Ross Perry •Christopher Hegarty •Tom Skogsrud •Kim Skogsrud •Anthony Marenghi •Adam Hunter •Gregor Fotheringham •Josh Robinson •Jordan Wilson

RANGERS SQUAD: MIDFIELDERS
•Lee Mcculloch •Maurice Edu •Steven Davis •Matt Mckay •Alejandro Bedoya •Jamie Ness •Gordon Dick •Andrew Mitchell •Rhys Mccabe •Kamil Wiktorski •Ewan Mcneil •Robbie Crawford •Adel Gafaiti •Lewis Macleod •Jack Werndley •Robbie Mcintyre •Matthew Clarke •Callum Gallagher •Andy Murdoch •Darren Ramsay

RANGERS SQUAD: FORWARDS
•Kyle Lafferty •Steven Naismith •David Healy •Sone Aluko •Salim Kerkar •Andrew Little •Kane Hemmings •Kyle Mcausland •Callum Wyllie •Freddie Espling •Jamie Burrows


JG

Agree0 Disagree0

After tomorrows vote it's div3 and 12 more players walk. Then the players will be div3 freebee guys.

Agree1 Disagree1

03 Jul 2012 03:45:42
Another jim traynor classic in today's daily ranger. Exclusive... Secret talks to keep rangers in s p l well obviously not that secret if jim knows.

Believable11 Unbelievable0

It better not be true or there will be NO fans at any of the games.All this trying to blackmail, makes you sick.What a country never mind the football!

Agree8 Disagree0

Desperate stuff from a desperate man.
Surely we should do an Ayr Utd and abstain from the SPL vote tomorrow. We have a bigger conflict of interest than Ayr, yet not one tenth their decency, humility and integrity.

Agree6 Disagree1

Every SPL Chairman who didn't attend the secret talks will now vote NO as they were kept out.
Since there were no secret talks every Chairman will vote NO to Newco.

Agree6 Disagree0

Traynor's keeping emotions high.
Watch the backlash.
He's delivering a NO vote.
Who's playing who?

Agree8 Disagree0

Just been revealed CG is offering a punishment package!

I wouldn't be too surprised if he pulls this off. Depends how entranched the various chairs are. Romanov is quite capable of changing his mind.

Agree0 Disagree5

Hands up who wants to let Sevco5088 into the SPL as club12?
Only D&P put their hand up.

Agree5 Disagree0

We all need to know how our clubs and Chairmen voted.

All 12 votes need to be published. Openness and transparency as per Ally's principles.

Who will raise their hand to vote secco in? Not I.

Agree6 Disagree0

Jim Traynor is the biggest scaremonger allowed in a national paper. He is a total digrace to his profession and should be made to resign immediatly for his over the top reporting in the last few weeks.
I for one will no longer buy the Record at any time or its Sunday sister because of its biased reporting. They have went "all out" in the pages to push for one thing only and that is that Rangers/NEWCO stay in the SPL... or first division? without out a care for any other opinions in the least.

Agree6 Disagree0

The more fat traynor writes, the more other clubs hate sevco, he's stirring up pure hatred, gets to the fans who put pressure on chairmen, it's backfiring on him, secret indeed, why would chairmen let a big fat clips know about secret meetings,

Ska bhoy {Ed039's Note - Traynor, I am not his biggest fan but I dont think the whole article is BS and there is some substance to it, and he will surely have his "sources")

Agree1 Disagree1

@1 You are a joke, what a post complaining about blackmail, but trying a dose of your own! ahaa.

Agree0 Disagree1

Haven't even read Jim Traynor since he came out with pesh like SPL chairmen aren't interested in the opinions of fans, only in the opinions of their bank managers. Has a football journalist ever got things as consistently wrong as this guy. Even Keevins and Spiers get it right more often. As for his Radio Scotland show he makes Chick Young sound like a footballing mastermind. BB

Agree0 Disagree0

When you see the calibre of so called
pundits at the Daily Record and the Sunday Mail I am amazed that people buy these excuses for newspapers. Three names spring to mind Jackson,Traynor and last but not least Burley. Enough said. Julie Ghirl {Ed039's Note - Julie you are obviously upto date enough with their journalists, so you must have some insight. Maybe you buy the odd paper now and again)

Agree0 Disagree0

02 Jul 2012 23:38:04
Fellow bears I suggest when we get back to spl all fans and fans groups get together and agree to take only 200 to away matches as this would cost clubs more than wat they would receive in gate receipts as they would have to provide policing, section of stand, catering etc...just a thought? What yous think?

Believable11 Unbelievable31

I just wish for once somebody would show some compassion for the impossible position Rangers have put the SPL clubs in. What's the point in wanting your once great club back in the SPL if you will simply use it as a catalyst for your bile. Grow up.

Shug

Agree10 Disagree2

So the next time we goto parkhead we take 200 fans, can't see that happening.

Agree3 Disagree1

Disagree, i would not like to see us organising boycotts against other clubs, i would rather the decision whether to buy a ticket from e.g dundee utd, should be left to individual bears, who can then decide if they want to stump up more than other clubs fans to visit tannadice, by the way if they send us down the other clubs will have suffered by the time we come back up, make no mistake about that.
One thing does worries me though, i really hope that all the animosity that has been built up over the last few months does not escalate when the football begins

JG

JG

Agree3 Disagree1

How about this for a way out idea. If rangers fans want to follow their team home or away they do it?

Agree4 Disagree0

Very intelligent I don't think

Whose fault is it that your Club is in such a mess?

You remind me of the child and lollipop syndrome

Agree3 Disagree0

Well up till now threats and boycotts have only made us more unpopular and have had the opposite effect from that foreseen by the likes of Sandy Jardine and co, so while I can see where you're coming from, I strongly disagree. BB

Agree4 Disagree0

Would you please stop posting stuff like this?
We are turning all the other clubs against us with plans like this just when we need their support to stay in football!

Agree3 Disagree1

I'ts SPL fans(as well as the others)that don't want you.How you going to get them together?They are together-they don't want Rangers in any form.

Agree3 Disagree0

What makes you think you'll ever get back in the SPL

Agree3 Disagree0

The reason that all SPL games involving Celtic and Rangers(IL) were ticketed were so that an appropriate level of policing could be arranged. Clubs will not be losing out because they paid for enough police for a 3,000 crowd and only 200 turn up. Get real.

Agree2 Disagree0

Oh my god? do we ever learn ? lets boycott etc etc etc no wonder we get such a hard time from others . Just for once look at this in an unbiased way and get on with the real matter which is a game of football. We have been punished for what our owners/managers/players have doNE over the years in OUR NAME without a care for others. We think WE ARE SCOTISH FOOTBALL but unfortunatly we were wrong and as they say THE CHICKENS HAVE CAME HOME TO ROOST. So lets do the right thing for once , ask for a place in the Third as is per the regulations and then take it from there. Lets build the broken bridges on the way with the rest of Scottish Football.
If not, i can only see disaster staring us in the face, because lets be honest everything no matter what MOVES ON and in time they will move on without US they may struggle for a time but within a short number of years they will re-bulid and just get on with the game, where will we be then ,,,,,, sitting in our IVORY TOWERS still passing judgements i hope not.

Agree3 Disagree1

02 Jul 2012 23:04:56
I think that we are heading for Div 3 and whilst upset not surprised or against the idea that that is where we should go - rules are rules and we accept that - would be good tho if the rules and possible punishments were known and not made by committee after an event. The question will be for scottish PL FA FL will you treat any future club in the future with the same rules and punishments - I certainly hope so !! With football under the spotlight, regardless of EBT outcome, there will be many other clubs facing tough scruitiny in the next couple of years, as well as falling revenue streams.

Believable13 Unbelievable2

OP rules are rules - Thats the problem, until about six weeks ago there was no rule for transfer of an SPL share from one Company to another and there certainly is no written rule what to do if that share is not transfered from one Company to another

JG

Agree3 Disagree0

Do you need reminded, again? Gretna? Livingston?

Agree3 Disagree0

I kind of agree ..but..rangers are already getting favours any other club if liquidated would have to start at bottom,the sfa spl etc are bending over backwards to try and accommodate rangers but other clubs are up in arms because they are saying if this was us we wouldn't get this treatment..so yes let's how rules in concrete that are good for the game and it's supporters but not just the chosen few

Agree3 Disagree0

Totally agree , now the clouds are going to start to dissove and we may just know where we are at, but i think some spl clubs may regret coming out and saying certain things as i think they might be next to go. I will say though that i dont include celtic in that as they have kept quiet which i believe until everything is sorted is the right way so fair play.
craig+babybear

Agree1 Disagree1

Agree matey but no chance of that happening. There will be calls for a widespread amnesty and it will be granted. It'll go like this: (A)half the SPL are folding, death of Scottish football if it's allowed to happen. We need to find a way of protecting our teams. (B) Aye but, how about the Rangers, they were a member team and got hammered. (A) aye but that was their own fault no (B) maybes but whose fault is it now, the league is folding and the Gers aren't even here. (A) yeah, that's their fault too. (B) so, big boys did it and ran way, is that what your saying. (A) aye (B) and the SFA should bend over backwards to help member clubs now. (A) aye (B) even though Rangers got hammered (A) again aye (B) what about sporting integrity. (A) what about it.

Agree0 Disagree2

Gretna ? Livingston ? Explain the relevance to the opening post please ? Gretna were liquidated with no buyer so ceased to exist as a senior football club ..... Livingston were relegated from the SPL to Div 1. They then repeatedly refused to provide necessary paperwork (not sure what for) to the SFL and the SFL demoted them to Div 3 for they misdemeanours - explain their relevance to OP please

Agree1 Disagree0

@2 why do you keep refering to gretna and livingston

Gretna resigned from the Scottish Football League officially June 3rd 2008; they had no ground, no players, no staff, the club was liquidated.

and your livingston example is way of the mark as well

Despite the new owners ensuring that Livingston's future as a professional football club would be secure for the next year at least by paying a £720,000 bond to the SFL,[68] on August 5 the Scottish Football League took the move to put Livingston in the Third Division. A breach of rules on insolvency was the main reason

JG

Agree0 Disagree0

02 Jul 2012 22:17:00
CHARLES GREEN says any questions about his stewardship of Rangers and the direction the club is heading in under him will be answered in the next seven days.

SPL clubs are due to formally vote on whether the club is granted access back into the top flight as a new company at Hampden Park on Wednesday.

Several have already announced they will rule against Gers and with an eight-to-four majority in favour of the Ibrox outfit required, acceptance looks highly unlikely at present.

Should the Light Blues be unsuccessful, it will then be determined whether the Light Blues will be admitted to the SFL instead and at what level.

Green knows he hasn't told supporters everything they want to hear as yet but maintains that has been with good reason and he has chosen his words carefully.

But he admits the time is coming to speak clearly and at the right moments and is looking for fans to remain patient for a little longer.

Green has this evening spoken exclusively to .tv and you can see his interview for free now by registering at the website if you have not already done so.

He said: "People who know me well say I talk too much but in reality the fans are angry here because I haven't said enough.

"It's because I haven't answered all the questions but over the next seven days, all the questions will be answered.

"I will always understand why the fans are worried because of the Craig Whyte situation and issues before that with David Murray. That's not going to disappear overnight.

"It is still frustrating, nevertheless, but there are times when we can't say anything because it could prejudice what is being discussed and what is talked about behind the scenes.

"There's far too much of Scottish football being played out in the media rather than being played out in the boardrooms.

"Having come through the pain Rangers fans have in the last four months, having to wait another seven or eight days isn't too much to ask in my mind."

Green has spent much of the last fortnight speaking to chairmen of other SPL clubs to outline why he feels Rangers should be kept among Scottish football's elite.

And he feels people are now in a better position to make decisions with an enhanced understanding of the economic effects relegating the Light Blues would have.

Green added: "I know the chairmen will listen. The problem some of them have to a lesser degree than I have here is fan pressure.

"I said to a number of them over the weekend that if they're concerned about their fans, they should come to Ibrox for a week and sit in my chair.

"Fans are the lifeblood of all clubs and without them we have no product so we have to engage with them.

"A lot of the decisions that are going to be made in the next seven days are going to be made by other people.

"Rangers have clearly got some input into the decision-making process and the team and I are going to present to the SPL chairmen on Wednesday.

"We'll put forward our case that we think needs looking at. We think the important thing is Scottish football and we need to draw a line and move forward.

"There is now a clearer understanding of the implications of football without Rangers because remember, this is not just about Rangers not being in the SPL.

"Lord Carloway may even just withdraw the licence to play at all if we go back to the tribunal.

"There are some big decisions and none are more material than Rangers being excluded from the league and the financial incomes this club drives for the benefit of all Scottish clubs."

J

Ps well put by green, he seems like he has been doing a bit of negotiating with other spl clubs, you never know

Believable6 Unbelievable9

Whats he gonna do about a licence? As of this moment sevco dont qualify.

Agree2 Disagree0

"There is now a clearer understanding of the implications of football without Rangers because remember, this is not just about Rangers not being in the SPL"

So Charles Green is suddenly a Scottish footbal guru and has all the nous to tell the rest of the SPL exactly which way its bread is buttered. Charles Green the saviour of Scottish football.

Agree1 Disagree0

02 Jul 2012 22:13:26
Sporting integrity! what a laugh. did rangers field more than 11 players ..NO !
It was financial mismanagement - not cheating.
Some could suggest Celtic did not show sporting integrity when they applied undue pressure on refs calling them cheats etc and even saying the sfa where biased. Is that sporting integrity?
At least celtic are not saying much and hopefully not putting the boot in behind closed doors. They at least have some clever people running their club, unlike the others. I would personally like rangers to go to div 3 and let all spl clubs suffer (some would go bankrupt). I do appreciate that this would be to the detriment of scottish football but the way people have been behaving im afraid im getting the silly head on too and wanting clubs to suffer like us.
So..in an effort to be rational lets hope that SPL clubs see sense..doubt it and the vote will be no, therefore div 1 next best option...would rangers gain promotion in 1 season? ..doubt that too..no squad and anyway, would I like to see a young team of boys be put under so much pressure, all div 1 teams wanting to put us to the sword and then all hell breaking loose if the boys cant make the grade...unfair to all! so this would leave div 3...football oblivion for rangers and all the rest.

My course of action (my personal protest) is to cancel my sky football subscription. Possibly the route of all evil in the whole sorry saga. Too much money in the english leagues and unfair distribution to scotland.
Ill buy my rangers season ticket..just hoping that all will work out ok over a number of years and we become a force again.
I will never go to a scotland game again (SFA have just been a bunch of happy amateurs with no vision whatsoever - wee blazer guys thinking like bowling club presidents..sorry guys the bowling club fraternity are much more professional than them)
I will never go to an away game again (with the exception of celtic - they will always go to ibrox). This will show all the diddy clubs how much they need our revenue stream! All the diddy men will squeal (chairmen) help and Rangers fans will show integrity and inform them that as they didn't want us we will duly oblige now and in the future.

Now.. Rangers..they did wrong (financial) and they have paid the price have they not. So why the blood lust. Its the other teams knowing that they may have a hope of becoming winners on the park. Well I gotta say they have two hopes and one is Bob!
celtic will win everything and so they should, they will be the best team. Dundee Utd (the jokers of the pack) will want some sort of cup play off system for the league (thompson already proposed this that the top six start again equally and play as if in a cup competion). Mr Thompson, where is the sporting integrity in that..the team who has most points should win the league.
Aberdeen....they will be hoping league reconstruction will be on the cards every season so they can avoid relagation (just like before)..St mirren..will go bust. Motherwell will go bust. Hibs could go bust..good youth set up so maybe ok. Hearts...would love to see their financial arrangements and financing become public... are they not owned or promoted by a bank (some banks have shown to have no integrity - perhaps Hearts promoters are different- hopefully).

Thats the rant over so now the rumour....some players who have said to the newco are actually playing a rouse on the authorities. Hoping that some leniency is shown on rangers and then they will sign for the newco (sounds unlikely though).

Another... Craig Whyte to be arrested within a fortnight.

Rangers till I die!

Depressed Ger but always a ger.

Believable14 Unbelievable15

As a Rangers fan for many years , I have just read your rant. It is very clear from it that you really have no knowledge or love of football.
Anyone who loves football wil admit two things at this point.
1- Rangers screwed up. Sorry no easy way to say it , it's our mistake. Bring on the punishment we will take it and come back stronger.
2. Scottish football will not collapse. No one wants it to collapse and Rangers really are not that big a club that Scottish Football will collapse without it.
You say Sky are the root of this problem.
No thet are not. I bet you watched The Old Firm matches on it. Sky have taken football from a pub sport into a multi billion global commodity .
The problem was not Sky, it was average players demanding extortionate wages , and poor managers willing to pay it.
What has happened to Rangers will happen to other clubs ( including some in the premiership ) but The SFL, the EPL and all other leagues will survive.
You are switching of your Sky, wow I bet Sky are gutted. How will they survive.
Grow up, someone will pick your toys up and put them back in your pram and meantime, I will make my weekly trip over to Scotland and follow,follow no matter what division we are in.
Paul Belfast

Agree5 Disagree0

Did I see a few wee compliments for Celtic there. Is it possible that your your hatred has waivered slightly? Come on man, snap out of it !!

Well written though, but I do feel that the SPL chairmen are trying to wangle you a reduced sentence. (Obviously, because it suits them.) But don't look a gift horse in the mouth.

The interesting thing about taking an interest in the last 4 months is finding out that not all Rangers fans are w*nkers. lol

Hopefully we'll get by this pish and back to the banter soon.

Shug

Agree1 Disagree0

Fool , of course there is a sporting integrity issue . If they had stayed within he financial boundaries they would not have been able to afford the wages of better players . Better players = better results , eg championships , cups etc . So blatant cheating is proved . Tainted titles for the teddy bears . They should be stripped of those titles . But that won't happen as sfa and spl won't want To upset rangers any further !!

Agree0 Disagree0

Stll not getting it I see. Rangers singed players and agreed to pay them a certain amount. But on the contract disclosed to the SPL it had a much smaller amount, the amount on which tax was paid. The rest of the players promised wage for playing was paid into an EBT, ostensibly as a discretionary loan they would not. Some players requested and got a letter/contract from Rangers saying as such. These letters/contracts were supposed to have been disclosed to the SPL but doing so would have jeapordised the tax free status of the EBT payment so they didn't. This meant that every Rangers player registered with SPL but whose letter explaining that the EBT was in fact payment for playing was not properly registered and ineligible. Therefore every match in which one of those incorrectly registered and ineligible players played should be awarded to the other team as a 3-0 win. Simple.

I'm sure there was a team a couple of years ago who through an actual administration error ws not properly registered. The guy hadn't even played yet but for the two matches where he had sat on the bench until the error was discovered, his club had the two results stripped from them including a comfortable Scottish cup win.

Agree0 Disagree0

02 Jul 2012 22:10:10
POPULAR
THE shape of things to come will be decided by close of play Wednesday. We should know by then if Scottish football has been big enough to edge back from the brink.

For months now there has been a savagery. The game has been ripping itself apart all in the name of fair play. Or was it sporting integrity?

Forgive me, the reasons for the crisis that threatens to destroy Scottish football have been lost somewhere in the lust to tear and shred one club. It's as though a century of hatred and probably jealousy have erupted.

And the handful of reasoned souls left in the game are fighting a losing battle to cap the flow.

The trouble is too many men with influence have been working not for the good of the game but to selfish agendas. They've done bad things in the name of morality.

They've abused their privileged positions and if there was any decency left in the sleazy, tacky football world they inhabit they would not be allowed inside Hampden this or any other week.

The dishonourable posing as protectors of the game's integrity by making up laws and punishments as they go along.

By arguing and pressing for more severe punishments and demanding that Rangers newco be stripped of titles and trophies won in the EBT years by another business entirely, they are inflaming and prolonging an agonisingly painful and damaging period. Anyone who believes that stripping the old Rangers of baubles will help solve this meltdown should be ignored, pushed aside because we are way beyond bragging rights.

We, Scottish football, are on the brink of total collapse.

Those who are consumed by petty matters and the settling of old, ancient scores have made it harder to find the solution, the compromise agreement that's badly needed.

One day the truth about the subterfuge, deception, and downright spitefulness used to prolong this saga might be told but right now those who are trying to save what is left of the game need to be given space.

And hopefully the right and sensible decisions will be made when the SFL and SPL meet tomorrow and Wednesday respectively. Everything, the game's fate and Rangers' chances of survival never mind revival, depends on these leagues of gentlemen, if of course they do meet tomorrow.

The situation is critical yet it seems we have two clubs threatening to block tomorrow's meeting. Stenhousemuir and Alloa have an objection. God help us.

Hopefully the meetings will go ahead and if honesty and common sense prevail we might just begin to emerge from the darkness and see clearly who is working for the game and who is working for themselves.

We might also notice that in our rabid rush to condemn and stone Rangers we have stumbled to the very precipice of catastrophe.

Another misguided step or irrational utterance and Scottish football will be in total free fall so tomorrow the SFL must do one of two things.

Either they decide to let Rangers newco - who already know they don't have the support of enough SPL clubs to get the share that would let them begin again at the top - kick off in the First Division or the way is cleared for them to start in the bottom tier.

But research has shown the game will lose £16million if Rangers are dumped in the Third Division and frankly that would be too great a loss to an already impoverished business.

Supporters, of course, are entitled to be heard but the question is this: Are fans - forget the ones who can't see beyond their own hatred - willing to see what they believe to be justice done no matter the cost or consequences?

What if their justice means Scottish football would be reduced to a truly moribund state that would make recovery impossible?

What if their idea of fair play meant our game would be forever locked out of the big boys' playground?

Morals and integrity are fine but we must all be sure we can cope with the fall out, which would be considerable.

Clubs will cut right back on numbers as we're already seeing with Hibernian who have just paid off Pat Fenlon's deputy Billy Brown.

Players and wages will be next, although the first real casualty is more likely to be youth development.

Mark my words, clubs are already being squeezed by their banks who have seen Lloyds get out with all of their money back from Rangers. The other lenders also want shot of their football clients and they'll be imposing tougher repayment plans on clubs, who will use these demands as excuses to make swingeing cuts on their budgets.

If they are asked to reduce spending by £300,000 a year they'll make it £600,000 and blame it all on Rangers.

But even by making savage cuts, a number of clubs will still go bust. This will be the true price of sporting integrity.

And when the doors are being padlocked let's have no wailing or tears because too many clubs saw Rangers' insolvency as an opportunity to promote their own agendas.

Yet what good has that done any of them, apart from allowing them to invade the moral high ground for a short while. Now, though, as they hobble down having broken their toes through kicking Rangers they are suddenly confronted with reality.

They have the power to deny this new club any chance of life but they'll be condemning themselves to a miserable, empty future. Without the millions a healthy Rangers and their fans help generate, Scottish football will decline rapidly. All credibility at home and abroad will be lost.

If this is what we wish then fine, deny Rangers an SPL share on Wednesday and SFA membership when the Appellate Tribunal sits again to decide a punishment acceptable in the eyes of the real law. If this is what upholding fair play means then let's go for it.

Let's take decisions tomorrow and the next day that will chime with whatever our notions of integrity are and kill the game.

After all, we can't put a price on justice, especially in football where justice is something to be kicked around without finesse or direction.

Of course justice should be about fairness and handing down punishments that reflect the nature of crimes committed. It should always be about observing the law according to the rules and principles written down. But that's the problem with applying justice in a morally bankrupt game.

Nothing seems to be written down. If it is there in black and white no one can understand it.

The SFL have called in lawyers to make sense of their own articles ahead of tomorrow's meetings and, of course, the SFA spent a couple of years revamping their own codes, leaning heavily on the finest legal minds. Yet, when a transfer ban on Rangers was imposed it was kicked out in Edinburgh's Court of Session.

It's a grotesque farce and one club chairman had to remove himself from the entire business yesterday. He had to plod along a west-coast beach in the wind and rain to try and clear his head.

The game is pulling itself apart because some want to settle old scores with Rangers while others strive only to make the most of the problems and strengthen their own positions.

Okay, but what's the point in being powerful within a game that will soon have no real significance beyond its own boundaries?

But here are a few questions those 'just' men should ask themselves as they file into their meeting rooms on Hampden's sixth floor over the next couple of days:

Is losing all credibility, standing in the game, SFA licence, SPL share and being treated with the utmost contempt not punishment enough?

No?

Then ask yourselves this:

Is going out of business, struggling to emerge as a newco without fan support and being banned from playing in Europe for three years and being branded pariahs not punishment enough?

If the answer is still no then there is no justice.

And there is no hope. The game, and not just Rangers, will be doomed.

Believable7 Unbelievable11

Traynor scaremongering because Traynor is scared he won't have a job. No more exclusives from Rangers! Traynor doesn't get exclusives from Celtic!

Agree5 Disagree0

OP, should you not make it clear that these are Jim Traynor's word. Otherwise it appears that you are passing them off as your own and there is a name for that.
Al

Agree3 Disagree0

While well written and fairly pragmatic the fact remains that you are pleading that Scottish football turns a blind eye to a club that had nothing bar contempt for a number of rules within the Scottish game and AGAIN, will you please all stop blaming the two big boys that ran away (Murray and Whyte). You all cheered merrily when they both unfurled league flags at Ibrox. "They have done things in the name of morality." True, but it's an improvement on "they have done things in the name illegality." "They've abused their privilege" (We are still talking about Rangers ex-chairmen here aren't we?). I don't think stripping Rangers of titles will end this fiasco either but if it is good enough for Juventus then if it is seen as a fit punishment (and I think prima facie suggests there is) then so be it.
"Subterfuge, deception and downright spitefulness" (again I'm thinking more Rangers here than anyone else.)
I am amazed that countless Rangers fans either ignored or didn't heed the signs regards Murray's crumbling empire nor didn't take on board suggested concerns over Whyte. You sell a company for a £1 it is not going well. You hear endless rumours of Whyte being not fit for the job, again not a jot of concern. Yet suddenly, the entire Rangers fan base are experts on the running of not one but forty two clubs in Scotland, remarkable! There are numerous reports regards the impact of this to Scottish football, The Scotsman said a £5.8m loss for the SPL clubs using a very rational criteria. I have no idea what the impact will be, the truth of the matter is neither does anyone else. The extremely fickle Scottish football loving public may well respond favourably to Rangers being seen to be punished to the full extent for their misdemeanours. I know lots of non-old firm fans who never set foot in either Ibrox or Celtic Park when their club play at either, it's fair to say Dens Park would perhaps profit from that. A potential six horse race for second place, that cant be bad for the SPL. So the money issue is certainly not nailed down to the penny regards the overall loss.
"No matter the cost of consequences". My question is, how much worse would Scottish football look if it did nothing? Pragmatic or not, it gives Celtic a green light (forgive the pun) to do the same in a few years time, knowing full well that along with Rangers we are indispensible and therefore can do what the hell we want. And I say that as a Celtic fan and I would be ashamed if they were tempted in that regard. For all their dominance I cannot for one second believe that La Liga would not come down appropriately on either Barcelona or Real Madrid under similar circumstances and lets face it regards dominance and impact on the domestic game Spain is about the closest model to Scotland that there is. Sadly the football bears no comparison.
Regards the justice part at the end and the three years without Europe sentence, not one club, not one chairman inflicted that on Rangers, well I lie actually, Rangers did it and Craig Whyte did it. If Charles Green had a pound for everytime it has been pointed out that these were not punishments but consequences of Rangers financial mismanagement then it's fair to say a bid for Messi would be forthcoming from Govan.
Long before this fiasco it has been said Scottish football was on the path to oblivion, so clearly the current model doesn't work, who knows maybe something as extreme as this might just be the shot in the arm that it needs, I don't know but what I do know is it is utterly doomed if a club, any club, can be seen to be too big to punish, despite their already brutal self-inflicted wounds.
Gaz

Agree1 Disagree1

Agree with Traynor for once, i think he has called it right this time

JG

Agree0 Disagree0

Going out of buisness and struggling to emerge as a newco does not equal punishment. Its a consequence of your clubs own actions, brought on yourselves by those that ran your club. Punishment for what now apperas to be at least a decade of cheating should and will follow.

Agree2 Disagree0

 
Change Consent